Search
4.5

100 reviews

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Fellow Mountain Cafe Reviews - 100

4.5
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Hamilton Greene

Great place to drop in for breakfast. Bacon Egg and Cheese breakfast sandwiches are great (bacon and brioche roll are tops) and solid cold brew. Expect to pay about $15pp for breakfast but well worth it.

Experience 5, Offerings 5, Value 4

(IG megna.photo approves)

Kelley C

This place is amazing. The egg sandwich on brioche and the chocolate cake are both incredible!

Aja Brandman

Super cute spot, has a modern farm to table feel to it. The caramelized Cherry focaccia was so delicious, highly recommended. There’s seating both indoors and out, and some cute merch.

Lauren Thomasten

Girl working up front at the cash register needs to take a hospitality skills 101 course- RUDE. I read another review about the unfriendly behavior towards non-locals. It’s the non-locals who keep the businesses in the area going! We sat and watched. Hope you make it, but you lost my business because of the unprofessional customer service.

Damel

Always a good place to go to get small breakfast, brunch and snacks. Cinnamon buns have a nice frosting that's not too sugary. Muffins are small and soft. Coffee is great. Decor is minimal yet clean and inviting. Recommend for singles and small groups of 3-5 people.

Devon Radkins

Quaint café with amazing breakfast options! I was very happy to see a gluten free bread option for their breakfast sandwiches, which is why I initially chose to come here. The gluten free bread was phenomenal. My husband got a cinnamon bun, which was so tasty we actually ordered more to-go to bring home to my parents.

Sarah Cardinale

Love Fellow! Beautifully located, great aesthetic, clean, super friendly staff and delicious food. I always visit on my way upstate.

steven anusiak

Friendly staff and tasty eats. I make sure to stop here every time I head to the CatSkills. Great sandwiches but you can’t go wrong with any choice here.

Lien Tran

Great café with a thoughtful menu, from lentil soup to egg sandwiches to killer cinnamon rolls. Hipster vibes.

NB

What a great addition to the village of Hunter, which up to now had little to offer (other than the mountain to skiers).

From the moment you step into Fellow Mountain Cafe, you feel welcome! The menu is varied - I had breakfast here earlier today with a friend. We both have 2nd homes here in the Catskill Mountains. The staff is very welcoming, there's plenty of street parking, the restaurant is warm with plenty of large tables and comfy chairs and benches, for small or large parties.

I had an amazing foccacia , which was too big for one person, so I got to take some home for a 2nd meal. My friend had a breakfast sandwich on sourdough toast, also a large portion.

There are lots of different coffee options - we had a latte and cold brew. Lots of chit chat in the cafe but the restaurant is spacious enough, that you can have a private conversation. I love also that there is a great outdoor porch if you prefer to sit outside.

Will definitely return! I wish Hunter Village would have more fun places like this.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload