Elm Street Bakery

Great food, coffee and atmosphere.

Food and coffee were very yummy. I'm giving four stars because they need to tweak their system. We waited a very long time for coffee, the barista was good but he could use some support.

Fantastic pizza and atmosphere. Stopped in after a hiking excursion and we’re pleased with dinner.

I like visiting the Bakery. The employees are down to Earth and very polite. I receive good service and the food is always excellent. They have a good selection of teas, coffee, and other beverages, including cane sugar pop. Pizza is made fresh ( before your eyes if you sit at the counter) and the pizzas chefs are good to talk with. Brick oven pizza at that. Also salads and other foods. Stop in and be prepared to be amazed.

Great wood-fired pizza and burger.

This place is one of the best places I've been to in East Aurora! It is so cool inside and it makes you feel all cozy. The brick oven pizza are so good, I haven't had a pizza that delicious in a very long time. If you get the chance, make the trip to Elm Street Bakery, you definitely will not be disappointed!!

The atmosphere is lovely and warming. The restaurant itself is quaint, with a rustic, yet classy, theme. The food was excellent and the waitress was more than helpful, as she helped us tremendously with our vegan order. Love it and will return.

This restaurant and bakery is phenomenal. The food has never disappointed. I've hit them up for lunch and dinner. I've grabbed pizza and heartier entrees. Even simple fare like Mac and cheese or chicken and biscuits comes out high tier. This place is well worth it. And that's not even taking into consideration the amazing baked goods. I always have to leave with a brookie or cowgirl cookie. I would go in debt if I lived any closer. If you're looking for a dinner spot to treat yourself, this is definitely the spot.

Cannot say enough great things about this place! The menu changes often and each meal is better than the next! The pizza is a must. You will likely wait for dinner on the weekends, but is perfect for a casual week night dinner. The breakfast pizza and sandwhiches are also amazing, but the coffee leaves a little to be desired. Everything else is simply amazing.

Pleasant ambiance and high quality food.
Some items only found here. Sandwiches and soups are delicious. Breads baked daily. Some pastries are a bit pricey. Wood-fired Pizzas also available.
Tony