Elm Street Bakery

Great bread. Orange cream bar was delicious although crust was a little hard. I'd order it again.

Somewhat pricey but very worth it and very cute. They have a great variety of super yummy, really well made baked goods as well as lunch items.

I got the grilled cheese--not sure the fancy name on the menu, but it was delicious. That being said, it's a grilled cheese with fancy jam and with the price tag ($10), it should have come with something like greens or housemade chips. I enjoy the atomsphere and supporting a local business, so I will probably return.

Outstanding coffee, sandwiches, and sweets. I highly recommend the baguettes, peanut butter cookies, and breakfast sandwich.

Went in for chocolate cherry bread, it's on there website. I was told they only make it for Valentine's day. Why have it on the website if you can buy it on the designated day it says

Good pizza the sauce was amazing everything well balanced if I could give it a score it will be 8.9 Luna's out of 10. The place had a very nice atmosphere great decor nice people.

Love this place! I come here for lunch when I’m in town for work. Great place for coffee, sandwiches and pizzas. Highly recommended.

This gem in East Aurora is a must visit not just for the delicious baked goods but also the well crafted drinks and flavor packed dishes on the menu.

On our visit we tried the oysters, octopus, pizza and sandwiches. All of which were superb. I was more than impressed with the octopus which was cooked to perfection and paired perfectly with the sauce and potatoes it came with.

And the plating and service did not go unrecognized. Looking forward to trying more of what they offer on my next visit.

Having lived in Italy for 7yrs, I’ve tried many local and regional variations on pizza. Elm St serves a truly authentic and delicious northern-style pizza that’s as good as any I’ve had in Italy; don’t miss it, there’s nothing anywhere close to this that I know of in WNY (including Jay’s).

I went here with company. None of us could say the coffee was better than brown water. The tea was good, but it came from a bag. The signature sandwich was served to us cold and with undercooked egg, wilted arugula and no smile. Keep in mind, I tipped in advance 30% on a 40$ order. The star is for interior design and the smell of the bread, but I can’t speak to the taste, as I left my sandwich on the table untouched. It looked and smelled so awful, even after they microwaved it, as it was served room temperature. I might return to the establishment if they change to making fresh sandwiches. It was a very nice setting.