Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
Review of Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is a popular coffee shop, bakery, restaurant, tea house, and vegan restaurant located at 146 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930. Open from 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM every day of the week, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee offers a range of premium quality coffee, baked goods, and vegan options.
Founded in 2003 by Jack Mazzola, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee aims to provide the highest quality products with a friendly and family-oriented atmosphere. The coffee shop has become a unique establishment among coffee shops in NYC, striving to create a community-like feel within its walls.
Customers have praised the deliciousness of the coffee and the variety of options available. The honey cinnamon latte has been described as "AMAZING" and worth the wait and money. The coffee is said to be very good, and the americano with cinnamon comes highly recommended. The iced Stella is also refreshing, especially during the summer heat.
While the coffee receives high praise, there have been some mixed reviews regarding the service. Some customers have mentioned that the staff can be rude and that the service can be slow, especially during peak hours. However, others have found the staff to be great and helpful.
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is a popular spot, so expect a queue during busy times. The shop offers limited seating, with outdoor seating available in the form of picnic tables and chairs. It is a family and dog-friendly establishment, welcoming all visitors.
If you are looking for a place to grab a delicious cup of coffee and enjoy a range of baked goods and vegan options, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is worth a visit. Just be prepared for potential wait times during busy periods.
From the business
"Premium quality coffee, friendly atmosphere, and great value – three tenets of service that Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee promises to deliver to their customers. This New York City coffee shop was founded in 2003 by Jack Mazzola with one simple goal in mind: to deliver the highest quality coffee and baked goods with an honest, family-friendly approach. Striving to create a community-like feel within his coffee shops, Jack makes it his top priority to treat all his customers and staff like one big family. Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee is a unique establishment among coffee shops in NYC."
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Michele Cipriani
Best espresso in the area. It would be a great addition to have ceramic cups for people that want to have their drink of choice on premises. Staff is friendly and they have a good selections of juices, energy bars and pastry.
Hannah Vogel
At the Amagansett location there was a wonderful young lady, I believe her name was Mishka, and she served me so kindly! I had the best Happy Jack (over ice with oat milk) that I've ever had from this store!! Definitely going back to tell her thank you! A must try this season!!
Rachel Reed
Great coffee (possibly the best out here). So glad they’ve decided to open this shop in amagansett
Jonathan Yellen
The stars are for much improved staffing this summer. There’s better coffee and food in Amagansett, but they’re open at 6 am and the service is great.
Jo Hill
I have a facial deformity and the two young ladies working today were eyeing each other when I was asking questions. I get this all the time but I guess I expected more from this place given its progressive outlook. Please do better. My day is ruined. And I feel I spent way too much on coffee and donuts here literally and d figuratively
Jonathan Yellen
Expensive for the quality. There are better places for coffee nearby. And the people behind the counter seem fundamentally unhappy to be there. Kinda sad. But very busy - so, I'm probably wrong.
Tana Alison
It is not a bad place and coffee is good but cashier and the barista were very rude. Cashier made face and talked with an attitude of “I hate my life, I hate this job, I hate you.” Never coming back to this place.
Kathy B.
Upon entering I said hello... may I please.... then ordered a donut $3.65, muffin $5.99 and coffee $3.25. Then paid and said "thank you" no reply of your welcome. Then I realized I was not given a receipt. " I asked if i could please have it" ( no one was in line behind me) Mishka, the woman who took my order and rang me up appeared very annoyed, she grabbed for the receipt then smacked it down. I yet again said, "thank you, have a good day"
still did not reply. Then a man behind the counter said "anything else" I replied "no thank you" as I put the sleeve on my coffee. "Ok then Happy Easter" he said. I replied "thank you but, i'm Jewish" his reply was "you are" I said "yes, I am it is Passover also." He replied "I know."
I am truly offended by the staff and they are extremely overpriced.
Tommy Sommer
Terrible cappuccino and not a great cream and sugar to coffee ratio in their cold brew. Pastries are okay. If a barista doesn’t know what a dry cappuccino is, they should just ask, rather than burn the milk. This place would not last a week in the city.
Ruxandra Bklyn
I loved my honey cinnamon latte. They have good coffee. That’s all I know.