Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
Review of Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is a popular coffee shop, bakery, restaurant, tea house, and vegan restaurant located at 146 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930. Open from 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM every day of the week, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee offers a range of premium quality coffee, baked goods, and vegan options.
Founded in 2003 by Jack Mazzola, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee aims to provide the highest quality products with a friendly and family-oriented atmosphere. The coffee shop has become a unique establishment among coffee shops in NYC, striving to create a community-like feel within its walls.
Customers have praised the deliciousness of the coffee and the variety of options available. The honey cinnamon latte has been described as "AMAZING" and worth the wait and money. The coffee is said to be very good, and the americano with cinnamon comes highly recommended. The iced Stella is also refreshing, especially during the summer heat.
While the coffee receives high praise, there have been some mixed reviews regarding the service. Some customers have mentioned that the staff can be rude and that the service can be slow, especially during peak hours. However, others have found the staff to be great and helpful.
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is a popular spot, so expect a queue during busy times. The shop offers limited seating, with outdoor seating available in the form of picnic tables and chairs. It is a family and dog-friendly establishment, welcoming all visitors.
If you are looking for a place to grab a delicious cup of coffee and enjoy a range of baked goods and vegan options, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is worth a visit. Just be prepared for potential wait times during busy periods.
From the business
"Premium quality coffee, friendly atmosphere, and great value – three tenets of service that Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee promises to deliver to their customers. This New York City coffee shop was founded in 2003 by Jack Mazzola with one simple goal in mind: to deliver the highest quality coffee and baked goods with an honest, family-friendly approach. Striving to create a community-like feel within his coffee shops, Jack makes it his top priority to treat all his customers and staff like one big family. Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee is a unique establishment among coffee shops in NYC."
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Henry Rosoff
Nothing quick about this quick serve place.
Rude staff, stuff listed on the menu, is actually not on the menu, hot inside while waiting 20 for a breakfast sandwich, would not let my toddler use the bathroom, which only happened because of long wait. Hate leaving reviews like these, it just terrible.
Gearoid Power
Popular..expect a queue.... But the staff are great!
BK
Staff know how to pour pre made cold brew, which is always good. Shame the hot coffee was undeniably awful and comes with a large side of useless customer service and passive aggressiveness.
Michael Corrigan
The coffee tasted like a hot cup of dirt. Old stale burnt.
Stephanie Vega
I went to this coffee shop since is the only cafe —other than Starbucks — than sells matcha lattes, unfortunately it was a really bad experience. When I saw my matcha i immediately knew it was cheap matcha; good quality matcha is very pigmented even when you use a little amount and it has a nice earthy taste, this was a very light pale green and all I could taste was the milk and it was also very grainy, clearly the barista didn’t know how to make matcha, since you have to have certain temperature, sift it and mix it for a decent time so the lumps don’t form. This might be a good coffee place, but they really need to up their matcha.
Waldemar Szlezak
Terrible service. The entire store is plastered with “order ahead skip the line.” Ordered pick up 30 mi ago and said ready by 255, show up waited until 3:05 and stood in line to check on my order. They lady told me they just ignored my order as there was a line in the store…there is always a line and if ordering ahead only works if there is no line, what’s the point? The attitude was worse of an f-off and that’s the most annoying thing. I would give it 0 stars but can’t.
Jackie McGovern
The cashier who took my order was very unfriendly. I have had her twice now and would love to tell management that she is not made for a customer service position. I asked to speak with the manager and was directed to the shift lead McCaila who was slightly more helpful with a credit that had to be returned to my gift card. The coffee is good, but the service is not.
Mimmy Gardner
The Coffee is superior, 5 stars. The shop is hectic, unfair conditioned and geared to have you buy your coffee and go. That's unfortunate, but you won't find a better 🍵 of brew on the East End
Yulia Fomenko
I went to Jack’s to get an oatmeal. It was listed as a four grain oatmeal: millet, buckwheat, steal cut oats, quinoa. But when I opened the container it was nothing but rolled oats mush - look at the photo attached!!! Why would you sell something that doesn’t match the description? Not to mention it tasted really bad, like absolute mush.
Serf Piedrasanta
Really bad matcha, paid $8 for it to have chunks and be grainy as well as super bitter. Female barista was obviously drunk and throwing coffee bags while giving me and my friends dirty looks for ordering coffee at a coffee shop. Go to blue bottle coffee ☕️ Instead