Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
Review of Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is a popular coffee shop, bakery, restaurant, tea house, and vegan restaurant located at 146 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930. Open from 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM every day of the week, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee offers a range of premium quality coffee, baked goods, and vegan options.
Founded in 2003 by Jack Mazzola, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee aims to provide the highest quality products with a friendly and family-oriented atmosphere. The coffee shop has become a unique establishment among coffee shops in NYC, striving to create a community-like feel within its walls.
Customers have praised the deliciousness of the coffee and the variety of options available. The honey cinnamon latte has been described as "AMAZING" and worth the wait and money. The coffee is said to be very good, and the americano with cinnamon comes highly recommended. The iced Stella is also refreshing, especially during the summer heat.
While the coffee receives high praise, there have been some mixed reviews regarding the service. Some customers have mentioned that the staff can be rude and that the service can be slow, especially during peak hours. However, others have found the staff to be great and helpful.
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is a popular spot, so expect a queue during busy times. The shop offers limited seating, with outdoor seating available in the form of picnic tables and chairs. It is a family and dog-friendly establishment, welcoming all visitors.
If you are looking for a place to grab a delicious cup of coffee and enjoy a range of baked goods and vegan options, Jack's Stir Brew Coffee is worth a visit. Just be prepared for potential wait times during busy periods.
From the business
"Premium quality coffee, friendly atmosphere, and great value – three tenets of service that Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee promises to deliver to their customers. This New York City coffee shop was founded in 2003 by Jack Mazzola with one simple goal in mind: to deliver the highest quality coffee and baked goods with an honest, family-friendly approach. Striving to create a community-like feel within his coffee shops, Jack makes it his top priority to treat all his customers and staff like one big family. Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee is a unique establishment among coffee shops in NYC."
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Jennifer LaFreniere
Two words: Delicious. Coffee.
Their coffee is 100% organic and you can tell. As their sign says, they only pull triple ristretto shots in their espresso drinks and it shows - rich and smooth with minimal acidity. The iced Stella was particularly refreshing with the summer heat.
I’d say this is more of a grab and go coffee joint, as there is minimal seating. If you’re looking for a place to sit and chat, you’ll likely want to go elsewhere.
Rebekah S
Jacks stir brew coffee is a hot spot for all things coffee, iced coffee, hot chocolate, lattes, espressos, baked goods, and snacks. It’s a cute set up and gets very busy. There is seating outside with picnic tables and chairs. Family and dog friendly!
Arpit Garg
We were stating at Hamptons on vacation and found this gem of a coffee house.
Jack’s is a local coffee shop and people there were very helpful.
We grabbed coffees and quick bites. Will for sure visit again when in the area!!!
Dave Stoker
Jack’s has great coffee and breakfast. Their cold brew coffee was some of the best I’ve had. The homemade biscuits are great and make for an awesome breakfast sandwich. The donuts were good too. There were lots of vegan friendly options and unique “local” coffee drinks. Things were a bit pricey, but it was worth it.
D I
Nice local coffee house. We ordered two fine cappuccinos, the chocolate crescent roll could have been better. Friendly and efficient service. Some seating. Ample parking. We shall return (but not when we need to use the restroom, because it's closed to customers).
paul enea (Paul E)
UPDATE: we decided to give jacks on more try and in spite of our previous disappointment, this time our servers couldn’t have been more pleasant and the coffee (as well as the matcha) were truly amazing! Really pronounced flavor just the way I like my coffee. Two shots were more than enough in my iced latte. I guess everyone is entitled to a bad day every so often. So from one star to five stars! Best coffee I’ve had in a long while. Thank you Jacks!
Long wait. Rude employee. After waiting on a long line we greeted the counter person with a smile and ordered a green hornet which is a menu item with its own chalkboard (see pic) and we were told they don’t make it anymore. We then asked for an iced matcha tea latte and were told they couldn’t make that either bcuz they were out of matcha tea. No attempt was made at offering us anything comparable and the place was mobbed so we walked out bewildered. Employee seemingly could care less. We decided to spend our money at a place that actually deserved it. First and last time at Jacks Stirred Brewed Coffee. This was the Amagansett location btw.
julia gometz
Jack's latte (honey cinnamon latte) was AMAZING. Worth the wait and money. Loved my biscuit breakfast sandwich to even tho it took a long time to make. I asked for a side of homemade jam. Delish!! Going back for sure.
Connor Leahey
One shot in the lattes? Cmon now. I need three coffees to start my day.
Bitsy Metcalf
Aside from medium iced coffees at $8.00 and a busy crowd from 8:30-10:30, Jack's is a heavenly coffee shop in the heart of town.
It's filled with local personality and an all around great coffee shop experience.
sofia o
Absolutely loved their coffee!! I got the honey cinnamon latte with oatmilk and it was one of the best I’ve ever had. I love all the vegan options they had to offer. Very yummy. I was excited to try the black out donut and it tasted like a normal non vegan donut. Overall, very well worth the price.