Turtle Gut

We really had a fixing for a sandwich from Rita's and when we went we noticed it changed over to Turtle Gut. We wanted to give them a shot and we were disappointed. We don't get the name. The menu was so small and limited and not posted anywhere other than on papers at the register or front door. Bagels were not good and barely had any butter on them. I got a blt that they make on a potato bun. I thought thought they would toast it like flattening it on the griddle, but it was just fresh out of the bag. I also asked for mayo, but they don't have it. They only have their own aioli. How do you not have mayo? So I asked for no aioli so I can take the sandwich home and put mayo on it. I get it home and it has aioli on it. The sandwich was so small that I was still hungry. It was like a light snack that didn't justify the price. The only good from it was the thick bacon was good and the tomato and lettuce were fresh. But unfortunately we will not be going back.

Great coffee and breakfast sandwiches, I got a bec and a cortado and both were delicious. It’s so refreshing to find a good ambiance + great quality spot in this area that lacks of options if not I think this is the only specialty coffee you can find.

It’s a great experience, amazing foods and service. Staff are extremely knowledgeable . The soft serve icecream with the topping especially the caramel is everything.
The view is also so breath taking and inside is so clean . Will definitely go back for sure! So welcoming.

Nice atmosphere and friendly owners. However, I ordered a pumpkin cappuccino and received a very small cappuccino which was quite bitter and not as sweet as I would have liked it to be.

Awesome sandwiches. Tried the sausage and egg (out of this world- local blueberries and sage) - and the BLT which tasted like a shake shack burger but higher quality with local tomatoes

Great breakfast sandwiches and cold brew! Such a cute new place to try. Excited to come back and will definitely recommend.

Went to check this place out tonight for the first time. The service was great, burgers and fries were delicious, and the view of the sunset on the bay was perfect. We will be back to check out the breakfast and ice cream.

Unfortunately won’t be going back here. Breakfast sandwiches are served on hamburger buns with one piece of meat and a slice of cheese. Very expensive for the little food. I also got an order of the hash browns which we’re soaked in oil and covered in so much salt they were inedible.

I don't think they're ready for prime time. I assume this is a new place with staff learning the ropes and trying to find their niche. Limited offerings but pretty tasty for what is there. I feel bad going 3 stars but they have potential. Maybe by the time you try it they'll have the operation humming. (The cold brew is a hard pass)

This place is a great addition to Wildwood Crest. Excellent location next to Sunset Lake and the burgers are the best on the island!!
The service is so nice and make you feel like family!!