Cornerstone Cafe & Catering

The Cornerstone Cafe is everything a neighbor restaurant should be. The menu is a simple and well-executed with all the classics and some interesting additions. My party, generally sticking to the basics, had a cheeseburger, meatloaf, and a Jamaican jerk chicken pasta. Everything was good, especially the pasta.

I did not order a drink but there was a full bar available. The staff happily accommodated us and kept us informed when there was tiny a delay on decaf coffee. I would definitely recommend dining here if you are in Monticello and are looking for a solid home cooked meal.

I've eaten 100s of ruebins in my life and this one takes the lead. Great service and friendly place.
Thank you for making good food.

The Cornerstone staff went above and beyond tonight, our whole family really appreciated a “home cooked” meal while recovering from being sick. The special notes on the boxes made us all smile. Thank you for the amazing food!

This place is great for a quick bite or a casual meal. Great selection of menu items. Even has a selection of adult beverages.

We've been here several times over the last few months and their food is consistently good. Service has been friendly and professional. The rosemary parmesan fries are worth the upcharge. Fantastic!

The pie is spendy at 7 bucks a slice and was just so-so. Not sure if I'd get pie again.

Love this place, glad we found it.

Quaint cafe with delicious homestyle food and beyond friendly staff. A must stop!! We will return!

Very good home cooked breakfast. Small town service. Prices are average.

The initial review States Cafe fare this is well beyond Cafe fare!
If spotless is important than eat here!
Phenomenal food and the parmesan french fries will have you licking the bottom of the dish like I did!!!!!
They serve liquor and homemade cake... What more do you want?!!!

One word, "desserts". This little joint has great food, coffee, and a very friendly staff. Definitely take the time to check out their full menu. However, the real reason to stop at the Cornerstone Cafe is to try their unbelievably well made desserts. I have to warn you, these house made sweets are incredibly addicting.

Make sure to call in and place an order 3 days ahead if you are interested in purchasing an entire carrot cake or French silk pie. These two dissappear fast =)

Good staff, but food served cold with quite a bit of hair and flat room temp pancakes. Did comp the hair plated meal as especially bad.
Others must have better experiences because always full on breakfast hours

Had the Jerk Chicken and could not stop eating it. And also had the Reuben which was just as good. The portion size was large but not overly large. It is definitely recommended for anyone to stop and try their food. The only complaint is you cannot buy a whole pie you have to buy it by individual slices which comes to a lot