Bean Counter Bakery Cafe

WOW!!! TOTALLY WORTH A STOP!!! Got a breakfast sandwich later in the day and it was great , also got a few bakery items that were great as well and wanted to try many more of them ,there were alot to choose from and all looked delicious, the coffee was awesome as well , there cakes look amazing as well ,the lady behind the counter was great and super helpfull ,I would highly recomend this .

An AMAZING experience working with them on our wedding cake and gender reveal party for our sister

Delicious cake, wonderful service!! We needed a baby shower cake 3 days before the shower and had heard great things about the Bean Counter!

The owner, Alice helped us design the cake and made cupcake suggestions. She was knowledgeable, patient and very helpful. Her passion for her business and her love of what she does shines through!

Our order was ready on time and everything was perfect!

The cake and cupcakes were delicious! One guest even remarked that Alice's carrot cupcake was the best he had ever tasted! The strawberry snowflake cake was a big hit as were the other cupcake flavors. I can't say enough about our experience with this bakery and Alice herself. We highly recommend the Bean Counter!

LOVED this place! They did our wedding cake and Alice made it exactly how we wanted it. They are really open to what you want, not to mention their cakes taste so good! We were also able to get gluten free and vegan cupcakes which I was told were really good too. Highly recommend for weddings

First, wasn't impressed with the pies except for the GF pecan. I was told by family it was delicious. Second, when I went to pickup the pies after waiting 22 minutes in Rte. 9 traffic I was told the pies went delivered yet from their other facility. Not even a call to let us know they weren't their and we would be notified when they were. WASN'T HAPPY!!!! Had to go all the way back again!!!!!

My husband and I aren't even cake people but our cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious! Alice was great to work with - it is hard as the wedding approaches finalizing details and Alice took it upon herself to email our venue for a final guest count which we appreciated so much! We bought our own cake topper and had our florist provide cake flowers and our coordinator left all that on the cake table and Alice handled it all. We saved the top tier but on our first anniversary Alice will bake a fresh top tier for our anniversary!
Alice and staff really know what they are doing and the cake was SO good!

I ordered a gender reveal cake after reading all of the great reviews for this company. After multiple back and forth calls about my order accurately being placed, they assured me they had the correct order. My doctor had to call multiple times to verify that they had the correct gender. After talking to the owner, I was told they did.

Come day of the gender reveal party, with multiple family memebers traveling from different states, we cut the cake to find a WHITE inside, leaving us wondering whether we were having a girl or boy. I laughed. With the poor customer service I experienced throughout this process I was not surprised at all by this outcome.

On the plus side…. at least they didn’t put the wrong color inside…

I ordered a cake for my sons baptism there was a mistake with the sizes and prices. Thank you so much Alice for taking caring of the mistake and handling everything so respectfully and responsible and taking these comments seriously.
She is a very kind and responsible women in her job. Thank you so much for everything. The cakes from here are definitely good my family and I enjoy them so much.

Alice and the Bean Counter were so excellent to work with during our wedding planning process. They catered to what we were looking for. We had a small cake (which was so yummy) and mini pies for our guests and it was fun and everyone said how great it was. Thank you to the Bean Counter for making the planning process easy and delicious!

I loved the espresso and coffee items I've gotten here. The last two times the baked good we purchased from their display (cupcakes and tarts) had an off taste. I'm not sure if it was a weird fridge taste but it permeated the outside of all the treats. My son would not even finish his which made me realize just how off putting it was. I think if you custom order a fresh cake you would be okay but I won't buy any baked goods from here in the future. Lattes were still great and the service was exceptional as always!