Cotten's Downtown

The waitress needs to pick a new profession and the busboy needs not to be so easily influenced by bad behavior and poor service. If you can't poach an egg bc you don't have the equipment don't cook me a fried egg expecting me eat it. The meal was fine otherwise, but I don't want free. I want people to run a business like they have good sense and common courtesy. Also throwing shade and being disrespectful to customers will not help your business make the kind of money it could make!

Sat at the counter in front of the grill. The grilling onions melted my mascara. I loved it! The home made onion rings were sliced thin and fried crispy. The OF egg burger on a grilled bun was scrumptious. The perfect lunch.

Very poor service and very unprofessional. Our waitress failed to serve my party adequately and was very slow despite there only being two other tables occupied. The burgers were great but I'm sad to say that because of the service, I will not be back.

This place was awesome! Went in to pick up a DoorDash delivery and found a new spot for lunch! Fantastic service, I loved the old diner feel. I'll be back... with friends.

Food was fresh and hot good quality and tasted very good

We ordered from Waitr at 10:22 and the delivery time said 12:53. I thought that was strange so I called and the lady who answered the phone sounded annoyed to answer my questions. When the food arrived it was cold, bland and not to mention they paid no attention to the choices I selected for my order. My order was wrong and I couldn't even eat my food. Never ordering from here again.

Great fresh, hot breakfast with a fantastic diner atmosphere! Thanks to our great server and cook this morning!! The wheat toast was SO tasty! Made fresh on the grill!

Very friendly staff, Food is very bland and absolutely saturated with butter/lard. The place is old/hot and filthy, you eyes will burn while eating from poor ventilation. For the price much better food can be had around the area. Still not sure what makes it so famous... I sure expected better

Waited 45 minutes for 2 burgers that was over priced. The cook has a beard that's too long and he never change his gloves and keep wiping his hands on his apron. He was very rude when I asked why the prices of the burgers aren't the same as Oak Park since they have the same name. Will not return to this location!

All day breakfast, the best hamburgers in town (imho), friendly wait staff and fast service. Opened in the shell of the old Mary Ann's. Other than updating the POS to a modern tablet based interface and WiFi if you ask Kate (owner, cook and chief bottle washer) nicely for the password, the place keeps it's diner setup intact and still looks and feels like Mary Ann's but Kate is much nicer than the old guy that ruled the griddle in days past. She's shares cooking duties with a few short order cooks, add a friendly and smiling wait staff, a clean place to eat right downtown. But, leave the pretense at home. Good food, good people, GREAT PLACE!