Cafe Neo

Wow what an awesome surprise find on our road trip!! Truly a gem of a little place right off the highway (do not pass it up just because it’s next to the gas station convenience store!!!). Fun coffee, tea and lemonade drinks plus great breakfast sandwiches. Definitely go for the Loukoumades Greek donuts too - the traditional style was really yummy.

Taylor was super helpful and so fun to chat with too! If this was in our town it would be a regular stop. ❤️

Great place all around. Great sitting areas! I love the decor. Eli is definitely a people person! I could tell that many locals come there repeatedly.

I will stop in again in my travels as a truck driver.

I have driven by this place many times on my way to Indianapolis. I’ve seen the signs on the highway for coffee and what sounded like delicious Greek donuts! I pulled up and saw that it was a coffee shop in a gas station. My heart dropped. My adjusted expectations were not even met. Took two sips of the coffee tossed the rest. Ate all of the donuts and the last two were hard to choke down. Point me to the nearest Starbucks.

Best stop of this road trip (and many others!)! Simple, fast, yummy food made fresh to order and the loukoumades took me right back to Greece! Super nice staff and a great value.

What a pleasant surprise! I am very picky about my coffee as I own my own coffee shop. This place was excellent. I’m used to not being let down because of my high standards for coffee but I loved this place. We bought the iced white mocha and the americano. The guy working the window was gracious and kind. We travel from Indy to PA a a few times a year and this place will
Now become a stop for us every time.

FRESH DONUTS MADE TO ORDER. What else is there to say? Lots! This is probably the best cafe I've been to, anywhere ever. There are big comfortable couches and chairs in the sun. The sandwiches are made with locally sourced meats. The butterscotch cold brew was delicious. They have about every drink you could think of, every syrup flavor, and this summer, they plan on adding ice cream. You can buy the coffees and syrups, as well as snacks and knickknacks from Greece.

We were served by the co-founder, who was running the shop single handed. He was very nice and guided us quickly through our orders, then brought out the yeasty fluffy donuts covered in cream and sugar. The whole place is a vibe, but if you must, there's a drive thru or online ordering. This is an OASIS along I-70 east of Indy so we will be back at every opportunity.

Cafe Neo is one of my all-time favorite coffee shops in east central Indiana. Each time I go there, whether in the store or the drive through, the associates are very prompt and friendly when taking your order. They are also prompt at making it. The specialty coffees have very consistent, deep flavors that you would hope for. When you come to Cafe Neo, you can expect top quality service and products during each visit. I highly recommend this coffee shop.

We stopped here, by chance, when driving through and getting gas. This cafe is attached to a gas station, but that does not take away from it at all. The interior is very clean, well decorated, and has plenty of seating. In addition, the staff was very polite, and all the food, including the Greek donuts, were made fresh. This is a hidden gem!

I have to say, the atmosphere at this location is nice. Comfortable and homey feeling. Worth noting, they do have a rather limited menu for hot foods, but their drinks are top notch. Very enjoyable.

Edit: fixed review due to the menu now reflects the additional charges.

Really comfortable and clean little cafe attached to a dumpy gas station in the middle of nowhere. Tasty ham and cheese panini and really great iced coffee. Very pleasant stop off the highway on our road trip. Comfy couches and cute little tables.