Blue Mountain Beach Creamery

Waited in line for about 20 minutes just so I could ask them if there's any gluten free options. They ignored me until they were ready to take my order. When I asked she just said no, I was like " is it a cross contamination problem? Because we can make that work." She replies abruptly, "no". I find that hard to believe that the sorbets have gluten.... I'm sure the ice cream is good here but it's served with a nice scoop of a$$ hole. If your looking for people who care if someone has an allergy or auto-immune disease, go to Buddy's right down the street. They are very friendly.

My whole family loved the ice cream here. The variety isn't huge, but there's something for everyone. The homemade flavors are delicious!

I’ve heard good things about this place but as for my experience it was sub par. The gelato had a weird aftertaste that resembled alcohol or sugar alcohol. I really wanted to like it but it was probably the worst on 30A. We tried four different flavors and all of them had an aftertaste. The folks that worked here were very nice and helpful.

Very good ice cream. I had Peach and it was great. They were very fast. Cash only

Family said the ice cream was awesome but I knocked it down a star for no plant based milk options. Be prepped for lines and hope they can work their awesome magic with some oat milk options!!

So this is a bit blasphemous for a native Texan, saying that anything is better than Blue Bell, but this is honestly the best ice cream you’ll ever have. Don’t balk if the line is long - it’s a testament to how good it is and they move things along pretty quickly.

Very good icecream that is home made, but very pricey. One dip in a cup or sugar cone is $4.50. If you want a waffle cone that is home made it costs at least $1.50 extra. There is no inside seating that I'm aware of. The icecream melted fast. We should have gotten them in a cup. No way to wash your sticky hands off. We both had banana pudding. It was great, but the taste didn't justify the cost. Jersey icecream is just as good in our opinion.

Great little ice cream place, but be prepared to stand in line. Also, they are not giving out samples, so you have to hope you like what you order, which can be difficult with kids.

Staff was friendly and answered our questions. They have a good variety and it’s not too expensive for ice cream. I didn’t find it particularly special so I can’t give it 5 stars but I was satisfied with what we got. Wish they had a few other offerings other than just sprinkles and gummy bears to complement ice cream. Brownie bites or cookies to make ice cream sandwiches would add a lot in terms of value to me because they pair so well with ice cream. Also, accepting card should be another step I would recommend taking in order to enhance the business. It costs nearly nothing to operate a square card reader and you can just use your phone and tell customers it’s an extra 3% (that’s what square charges to use their service) is they want to use card. This is a simple and inexpensive step that could be used to assuage many unhappy customers.

Best ice cream ever!