Blue Mountain Beach Creamery

I have never had bad ice cream here. All the flavors are unique and delicious! Sometimes the line May be long but the wait is generally short since the line goes quickly.

Wow....saw previous ratings and had high hopes....drove up and saw the line and knew it was going to be great! Had the Caramel Cheesecake Cookie Monster...normally not a waffle cone guy...but the young man taking my order really recommended it...they make them as you order...the smell hits you as you walk up to the place...well worth it! Delicious!

We go here everytime we go to Grayton Beach, I love the changing flavors (always something new to try) and the taste is always great. It's a local place and they make their ice cream, it is really good! Don't be shocked at the prices, it is worth every penny

Great place to get a scoop or two of ice cream! Homemade so flavors are always pretty unique, as in you wouldn't find them at the grocery store or in a Baskin Robins. But if course, they do have the standard flavors! It's a little bit on a pricey side at over $4 for a single scoop on a cup, but I have to say it's a pretty decent sized scoop! Always busy, so the best times to go are between 10:30 & 12:30 or 4:30-6:30! Most people are going after lunch or dinner, so hit it when everyone else would be eating... if you can! Lol

My wife and I stayed at blue mountain villas and the second night we were there we decided to walk down to the creamery. Probably the best ice cream either of us have ever eaten. We went back night after night. It was great. The waffle cones were still warm one night and the best anywhere. Our son is getting married in October and we rented "Coast on Inn" which is right down the street. We will be there every night except maybe the wedding night.

Be really nice if the people that worked there knew how to listen and correctly take your order. Be even nicer when you mention you don't have everything you ordered, you don't have to listen to lame excuses of why you didn't get you order. Not my problem if your employee can't listen and take down an ice cream order correctly. Won't be back...your customer service sucks! Get employees that know how to listen

Very soft ice cream. And very expensive. With tip $20 for two hot fudge sundaes and I’ve had better - much better at your good ole Dairy Cream. Next time I have the urge I’m driving to Publix.

Ice cream was awesome. Had thin mint and brownie batter with a cake cone. The waffle cone looked amazing and is homemade but we didn’t try it. Will definitely return.

The icecream was reallyyyy good. And generous with toppings!

Delicious homemade ice cream with many flavors to chose from! Although a short drive from Seaside and Seagrove, it's a great place to grab a cool snack. There will probably be a line of people. Expect to wait at least 10 minutes or so, maybe more in the peak season.