Blue Mountain Beach Creamery

The Blueberry cheesecake ice cream is hands down the best I’ve ever had. My wife had the cappuccino and my daughters had the sherbet. They were all really good. We were there Aug 26th 2021. Definitely will be going back next time we are at the beach.

I’ve been here every night on our trip they Literally have the best root beer floats and orange dream float! I’m from Texas and this is the best I’ve cream I’ve ever had I’ve only had the floats though with the vanilla ice cream but the vanilla is so good! Usually their is long lines but they go fast maybe waited 15 mins! I left off a store due to only cash I never carry cash with me just my card and they don’t except cash!

Best ice cream stop. You can't go to Blue Mountain Beach without stopping here.

Delicious and some great unusual flavors!

This ice cream stop is so good. I was impressed by the quality of the ice cream. I got the cappuccino crunch (which was incredible) and I could quickly tell that not only was the ice cream made here, but the chocolate chips along with the toffee was clearly made from scratch too. Between my wife and I, we tried 4 flavors and they all delivered. Tourist or not, this place lives up to the reviews.

Really good ice cream! Service was good. Do note that it is cash only.

It was so yummy! I got brownie batter and my husband got the blue panda (sugar cookie ice cream with Oreos) both with waffle cones. Quick service. It is cash only. Definitely worth it

Ice Cream and shakes were very good, but if you get there after 7 be prepared to wait. The shake shack had only 2 people working and even though the line looked short it took almost an hour. The ice cream side was usually faster, even with a longer line.

Always a favorite for my family! Nights during our annual trips when we can't make it by 10pm we are always sad. Literally we try to make it every night when we are in town!!

Also I suggest to branch out and try new flavors. They have some creative and unique ones that are delicious!

There are things you do on vacation that make special the experience and signify that you've been there and participated in local customs. This iis one of those where you wait in line behind 30-40 people, families with their squirming kids wondering if they'll still have that flavor when you get to the window, also wondering if the $8 a person for the creatively named flavor will be worth it and if the long walk to wait in this line will be worth it. It was worth it! Everyone loved it and great memories were made.