Bay Islands Coffee Company

was driving through gainesville and stopped here for a regular cup of coffee as it looked cute and had good reviews. Unfortunately the coffee was burnt :/ mucho triste way to start off a long travel day

My Son and I have been customers for over 10 years, even with the change in ownership, our order is correct, and the employees are always kind, and professional! Customer for life!!

Very good coffee, less expensive than Starbucks, quicker and much friendlier service. We will make this place a destination when in Gainesville.

The employee was really rude as soon as we pulled up. Food was okay. If you’re a coffee lover, this isn’t the place for you. Coffee was very weak.

Amazing shop, my only complaint is that they open up late on the weekend and that's when I need coffee the most. Hard to knock them for that though, 5 stars, you gotta go

I've been in and around Gainesville for a long time and can't believe I only now stopped by this place. The coffee is very enjoyable and the prices are reasonable. I recommend it.

I'm a Starbucks fanatic. However, the #1 rated attraction in all of Gainesville is Bay Island Coffee, (according to some rankings...) It doesn't disappoint!

Super service and care. Locally owned, quality coffee and bagels - a lot packed into this little place.

Breakfast is warm and satisfying. Smoothies are delicious. Service is fast. There's always a line for a reason!

Great Coffee and Incredibly Consistent Breakfast Sandwiches. Even when the line is several cars deep, as it often is... it is worth the wait!