Scaturo's Baking Co & Cafe

Best pizza I have had ever. And reliably good. Also they have breakfast happy hour every day from 5a to 8a. I loved the pancakes.

Very cute place and the staff is very nice. I've gone a few times - only ever getting breakfast food and I'll say I found the food alright. A couple different times things weren't thoroughly heated, though.

We were looking for a good breakfast place since we were staying in Sturgeon Bay. Our Air BnB host recommended Scaturo's. It's a little confusing when you first walk in. You actually take a menu, find a seat, and then order at the counter. Then you go back to your seat and they bring out your food. Then when you're done you pay at the bakery counter. It's actually pretty nice once you figure out what's going on. Lol!! I had eggs, bacon, sausage, and a chocolate milk. My wife had a Berry Parfait which she said was really good. We would go back.

Came in as a party of 8 on a busy Sunday morning, told there was a 30 min wait, which was fine given how big of a party we were and how busy they were. They seem to be coping with low staffing issues rather cleverly by seating guests, having them review the menu, then directing guests to order at a counter. Food is then delivered to the table. The problem is, without a designated server, no one notices when there is a hiccup. We were the hiccup. Apparently there was a technical issue printing our ticket in the kitchen, so we waited about 30-35 mins with no food (we were trying to be patient) before finally hailing down a staff member to see what the issue was (it was the lost ticket). We then had to wait another 10-15 mins for the food to be cooked. Hey, mistakes happen, the question is how does the business respond. They responded perfectly by apologizing, gifting us free pastries, and comping a substantial portion of the bill. When the food came out, it was absolutely delicious, and even though we were all a little hangry the first half of the experience, we left satisfied. I’d definitely dine here again and recommend it to others - but don’t be afraid to advocate for yourself if something seems off (because you won’t really have a server to advocate for you).

We were in town for an ice fishing excursion and looked forward to trying Scarturo's for breakfast as it was recommended to us by a friend. The website mentioned brunch so we expected the typical brunch scenario however this was not the case. The menu offered several individual selections rather than the buffet style which was fine except for the brunch level pricing. My husband ordered eggs Benedict. The serving was small and had deli meat ham rather than a slice of of regular ham and a serving of fruit for14 dollars. Not much for 14$ An offering of potatoes would have made it worth the money. My French toast was amazing

My wife and I stopped here for breakfast based on reviews. We were not disappointed. They were very busy but the staff still treated us kindly even though they were beyond capacity. The food was excellent. I like that the selections are a bit different than the ordinary menu offerings from other breakfast restaurants. We will be dining here again.

Very good food with an in-house bakery. You order your food at the counter. Then, a food runner brings your food to the table on palm leave "paper" plates. If you need a doggy bag, they will provide containers. We had quiche. Reminded me of the quiche the Schreiner's in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin used to serve. Overall, a very happy experience. Will definitely go back in the future!

Amazing coffee, amazing people. Love this place!

Was just ok for me and my husband. I had. BBQ pork skillet, he had an omelet. Everything served on paper, and you ordered at the counter. which really didn't bother me but I could have made better food at home. Even the chocolate milk was bland.

We stopped for the cherry pie, very delicious! The smells from the breakfast meals made it tough to just get the slice of pie.