Scaturo's Baking Co & Cafe

I have a friend with a large family who had a birthday but doesn't like cake. So I placed a special order the morning I left town for multiple cherry pies. Three birthday pies for my friend and their family, one for my work colleagues, and one just for myself. They were more than accommodating for my special request. I made myself busy around town while they were baked. In a couple of hours I was able to return to pick up my order. Amazing cherry pie. Highly recommend.

We stumbled upon this place while vacationing in the area and omg it was such a great find! The service and the food were stellar!! We had an amazing time and left stuffed! The food was fresh, and delicious and the sangria was to die for! 🥳🥳

Great food, atmosphere & friendly staff. You can eat inside our enclosed patio in back. Beware of baked goods! They will get you and you'll want more😁 back again! Better then the last. Update: Hanna there pastry chef made a costume banana birthday cake for us. It was Amazing, as all their baked goods are.

I really enjoyed breakfast here. People in my group ordered "not grandma's french toast", breakfast sandwich with ham sausage and bacon, chicken salad sandwich, cherry mimosa, sangria. All were very good. There is also a bakery here. I took home a loaf of cheese bread that was delicious. There are also pastries, cookies and other desserts in the bakery. They also have take home meals available. I did not try any, but they looked good.

Solid bakery and pastries! I had the chocolate donut, and the frosting and cake was perfectly done. Cherry mimosas/ sangria was alright but very tart.

Dog friendly, which is always a plus. Friendly staff, but disorganized, and quite chaotic inside (at least on the weekends).

Would recommend eating outside- weather permitting. Would definitely come back next time I’m in town and recommend you check it out.

Would recommend more outdoor seating, but space is limited, and they make efficient use of it.

Couple days ago we had the take home chicken pot pie meal. It was awesome feeds the 2 of us your 3 meals plus bread for a few more days.
Last night took home tenderloin tips.
Again delicious. We have been sending our guests from our motel for over 7 years
That says it all right there

Food is good! I tried the Veggie Wrap. Spaghetti to go dinner is a bit over priced. Haven’t tried it yet though, so hopefully worth it.
Also, the lady with glasses who is, I’m assuming, the owner.. meh, a bit impatient. The waitress on the other hand, very warm and welcoming.

No table service! Everyone blames it on staffing issues which I think people are sick of hearing.
Bought some cookies on Saturday and they were so dried out. Stopped back on Sunday to get a loaf of bread to take home and mentioned to the owner about the cookies and she said there’s the baker. His response was it’s due to the cold weather. How ridiculous! The owner didn’t care one bit. She was so rude. Won’t be in business very long with that attitude.

A must stop in Sturgeon Bay.
The salads are an art, the Italian beef sandwich is all made with fresh ingredients, all of it.
The pies and the pecan buns to die for.
These people work hard for the money, no joke.

Be prepared to drool over all of the delicious bakery when you walk in. The food is phenomenal, service is speedy, and the staff is friendly. We will DEFINITELY be back!