Off The Rail

Baked goods are amazing. The blueberry muffin was one of the best coffee shop muffins I've ever had (and I've had a lot!). Coffee is great and breakfast sandwiches are worth the wait. There's a crowd on the weekends, especially on summer Saturdays during the farmer's market or on racing weekends. Enjoy the quaint setting of downtown Elkhart Lake and dog and people watching while you wait. Friendly staff. Well managed. Check it out!

I’ve been coming in every so often for the past year and it has always been a great experience. Small but cozy, this place keeps busy during lunch rush. I haven’t seen it busy where people couldn’t sit, but I wouldn’t be surprised if that happens often. Sandwiches are great. Chips are delicious. In my experience their caramel macchiatos have yet to be beat. And service is exceptional! Everyone who works here seems kind and attentive. I came in during rush time and they forgot my sandwich, but they were extremely caring in repairing the situation and calling me by my first name, which just seemed so genuine from them in that situation. With all the reviews I didn’t think it really needed my opinion but I felt I should return the favor with a small review. I’m glad I came to know this place. This is definitely a place to stop by if you’re into cafes and in the area. Also shout out to Claire who’s usually at the cash register when I see her. She’s been sweet and caring since my first visit.

We have never been disappointed. Small town owned. Veteran run. Best coffee we have ever had. The flying Scottsman was delicious. We come here every time we are in town. Highly highly recommend.

Off the Rail is off the hook.
Tasty sandwiches and delicious coffee. Be patient lines can be long but worth the wait!

Lovely people, great coffee, and delicious treats! There are also amusing signs to read while you wait. :)

Fantastic place with lots of character. The staff is wonderful and the food is excellent. Chicken tortilla soup and BLT we're a perfect combo. Don't forget a drink and the addictiive seasoned chips! I will definitely be back!

Stopped in for a sandwich on a Friday afternoon in the high season. It was packed to the gills. The place is tiny, my husband ordered a Spotted Cow... They brought him a Stella. So no attention to details. It's a very popular spot for breakfast, we didn't try any of the bakery items or the coffee however. The sandwiches are all named after train motifs. The cheese was creamy and delicious. The roast beef we had was meh. We split the sandwich and chips. The sourdough bread was cut super thin. Value for money is not there. Most run about $8-9. The chips were seasoned really well so that was a positive. Overall, if you get claustrophobic then eat outside, prepare to wait and get the chips.

You may remember a cafe on this spot with another name from years ago. The new owners have improved everything, from the menu to the service. Even when it's busy, the wait is so much shorter than before! Great sandwich and beverage menus, and the outdoor patio seating is so much fun. Highly recommended!

DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY! OVER PRICED!

If you're looking for a snack, I guess stop here. Not meant for a meal. It's a cute place, but the sandwiches aren't too good. They microwave everything pretty much. Very small place, so don't go there if you have more than 4 people. The pop/soda they had was flat. The prices are too high for the low quality!

If you want a good treat, stop into the nice ice cream parlor down the street!

Very disappointed!

Been going here for a long time! Always great food. I love the atmosphere! Employees are always happy and singing to the music. Even with mask you just know you are being served with a smile. Great patio seating.