Castleton Pizza Place & Deli

Do not order pizza to go. Completely inedible they coated the bottom of the box in flower before putting the pizza in. Super disappointed. Complete waste of $20. Would give zero stars if I could.

This place just keeps getting worse and worse with the help they hire. I understand it’s hard to find people to work these days but there is absolutely ZERO quality control there. I asked for a high chair for my son and not only did they not bother looking for one in the deli area or the restaurant side but their excuse to me was it’s not really a kids place. It’s a FAMILY restaurant. You’re telling me that you don’t have high chairs? I don’t buy it.

Now the issue of the food. When you pay the prices they charge you expect them to at least TRY to pretend to make a half way decent sandwich. They took the meat out of the paper rolled up and left them rolled up on the sandwich and wrap with out separating or pulling apart the meat to put on the sandwich properly. It kinda sucked that we had to take apart our sandwiches and put them together so we could enjoy them. I used to like this place.

This used to be the only local place my daughter would eat pizza, I’m not sure what happened but the last two times we got slices the pizza was just different and not in a better way. It seemed flavorless with too much plain cheese and no seasonings. She won’t eat it anymore, we’ll try again in a few months.

I have been coming here for years but when the staff cannot give a appropriate time estimate for food I start to get upset. The last four times I have ordered it has been 15-30 minutes late. This last thirty minutes for a party in a large order I place well over a hour and a half before.

This place was awesome. The staff was so friendly. The variety of wraps offered wish I was going to be here longer and that they were local to me in NY
They would be my go to for everything on the menu. The pizza was delicious and fresh mushrooms not canned. The crust was so good. They had a good sized eating area but I was just picking up.

Called a day in advance to see if they could accommodate a larger order for a team (11 pizzas and 5 orders of wings). Raven, the night manager, was so helpful and assured me they could do the order and even made a special exception and delivered it to the pavilion on campus! I even had to call last minute the day of and change one of the pizzas and add a gluten free wrap and they said no problem! Everything was delicious! Thank you!

Awesome little place. Servers went the extra mile to make sure I got the meal I wanted. Pizza was perfect.

Ordered over 50 sandwiches for a college wrestling team. Got multiple varieties of sandwiches and all were very fresh with healthy portions. Staff was very friendly and we had not one issue with the large order. Highly recommended.

Ordered big mac pizza, and meat lovers, expecting wow!
Got eww!
The smell emanating on the way home was horrible. Hoping it was just the blue cheese my wife wanted for the wings (which I don't care for)
Unfortunately not, left a terrible taste in my mouth, no amount of alcohol. Nor mouthwash or brushing could overcome

I got a Stromboli that had raw dough and no cheese was melted inside and I waited around for the girl to find another girl to cash me out. I love the food there but I am disappointed.