Carigas island cafe

We had some Bailey’s French toast and it was slightly above average. It didn’t have a as much flavor as I expected, and there were only two pieces. The staff was really nice and personable, we had a great spot, and overall the atmosphere was really fun but laid back as well.

Great food, great staff. Highly recommend.

We had the tuna tacos, halibut rueben, lamb burger, and pesto salmon. All were very good. We're planning to go back at least once more before the end of our vacation. Friendly staff, chill vibe. Highly recommend finding this little gem hidden away in the boat yard!

Absolutely amazing food! The flavor combinations are spot on. 12/10 would recommend!

This place is flipping amazing. Sally and Randy are incredible hosts. Robby is a spectacular chef. Frank is one of the sweetest people you will ever meet. And the FOOD .... Tuna Tacos all the way! Or Cheeseburgers in paradise. You just can’t go wrong. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

We went there two days in a row. The first day we had lunch and the second day we had breakfast.
The lunch was very good.
The next day, I ordered one of their breakfast specials for $13 and I was surprised when only two slices of brioche french toast arrived. While the french toast was good, my meal was more expensive than my significant other's meal and I left hungry.
I provided feedback to the server and the response was "Well, brioche bread is expensive, I'm not sure if you know."
If I was warned that the breakfast special was two slices of toast, I would have ordered what my significant other ordered off the menu. He had plenty of food and left satisfied.
If you visit Carigas and you're hungry, clarify the portion size with the server to ensure you leave full.

I'm so happyyyy carigas opened back up!

Great people here along with great food. Might take a minute to get out of the kitchen, but it sure is tasty and filling. Would highly recommend. And the place has some really cool history. Would do go back here in a heart beat . Plus who doesn't love a good mimosa in the morning.

Great music, appetizers and drinks. A fun even.

This is the first review I’ve ever written and so well deserved.

A hidden gem for sure. We ate there our first day of arrival from being in an airport or airplane from 3am by 4 pm Wednesday we were starving and thirsty... I have to admit I was like this place really. Randy the owner his wife and our server Lori hands down amazing, made us feel like locals the second we walked in (this is a local hidden HOTSPOT) The seared tuna tacos were amazing, the drinks were not lacking at allll.
Thursday we ate a very expensive steak house in Red hook literally double what we payed at Carigas and got cold steaks, cold tuna steaks etc.

We came back for dinner Friday my fiancé’s birthday and it was even better than the first time, fish and chips (Grouper) was cooked perfectly, fresh, lightly breaded and steaming hot, my fiancé’s chicken Lasagna was also amazing, Free happy hour shot and literally the entire place singing and clapping for my beautiful soon to be brides birthday. We will go back a couple more times before we leave Wednesday.
Randy thank you for noticing the Texas team of four were back, thanking us for our business and returning, owning my own business as well THATS customer service!! Lori your just awesome, literally welcomed us with open arms and excited to see us.

Keep it up guys. We’re always booking a trip in July and Carigas will be one of our main lunch, dinner and drinks spots.

Much love, and continued growth..... The Texas team
Scott, Britt, Jeff, & Summer