Reviews (67)
Love this place!
What a cute coffee shop!! I started my morning here with a sugar free Hazelnut Wake me up! It did just the trick.
I’ve been wanting to try this place for a while and I’m so glad I stopped in after a Saturday morning workout! The staff was extremely patient, kind and knowledgeable as I waffled between some tasty items on the menu, and they were great about making recommendations and bearing with my indecision. Super prompt service, too. I had the Sunrise sandwich, which was the perfect balance of sweet/savory and not too heavy. Will definitely be back!
Super cute, quick service, reasonably priced and delicious. I will be coming back!
We looooove PB&Jays Café! My boyfriend and I have tried all their speciality sandwiches and a few of their hot drinks, we are never disappointed!
Delicious, reasonably priced, nice vibe, super friendly staff.
In Feb of 2021 I asked PB & Jay to help me with the purchase and delivery of a gift for a dear friend in the Fayetteville area. I live out of state. Kirsten was absolutely amazing. We communicated mostly by text because of my exceptional schedule at the time. And my friend enjoyed the products, the package was well packed. And Kirsten sent me photos of everything so I could see / feel part of this process. So grateful and highly recommend these folks. Hope to stop by sometime I'm in the area. Thank you PB&Jay and thank you Kirsten!
Best quiche I’ve had in a looooong time. And the chai is superb! Glad I found this little spot after a frustrating experience at the airport. Thank you!
Cute little coffee shop with some great breakfast and lunch foods as well. Visited on 2 different trips to the area recently. Quiche, muffins and the espresso bourbon brownie were all delicious.
Pathetic excuse for a PB & J. I ordered cashew butter and apple jam. The bread was cold. There was barely any nut butter or jam. And it was the wrong jam. I had them remake it. The bread was still cold. The jam was still wrong. For a $7 PB&J, are you kidding me? How is it possible to screw up a food item with 3 ingredients?! My 10 year old makes a better sandwich. Rip off.
Great food - got a toasted sandwich(apple butter, pecan, sugar bacon) and a lavender latte but there was definitely other things I want to try like the galettes and giant biscotti. The two negatives that dropped a star are the hours (would love Sunday or to be open later a few nights) and I was served on a paper plate with no explanation. I see in the other reviews they have normal plates so an explanation would’ve been fine (oh our dishwasher is broken today)… it just kinda brought the elevated PB&J experience back down to a child’s school lunch.
Best peanut butter sandwiches we have ever had.
Love this spot! The inside is soo cute and everything they serve is delicious.
It’s the cutest little coffee shop I’ve seen yet, clean, quiet, (despite being next to a daycare/preschool), a library is next door, and the staff are amazing. Just the thing for a boost of happy energy for your day. Do visit them.
Very calm atmosphere. Good coffee and chai tea lattes. Very nice staff.
This is physically the BEST PB AND J IVE EVER HAD!
One of the hidden gems of Fletcher. Great atmosphere inside and outside. Excellent location where you can walk a few feet to a playground (Kate’s Park). Quiche and bakery items were delicious. Friendly staff!
Sandwiches are yummy. Iced tea is very refreshing.
Very poor service. Extremely overpriced.
Delicious sandwiches, quiches, beverages and baked goods. The giant chocolate cherry almond biscotti is fantastic!!!