Casali's Grille

Wonderful first visit to Casali’s Grille!
We were looking for nearby restaurants when coming to the Benezette area, and we found a winner here in St. Mary’s.
Our server was spot on with service! We found out she had been on the floor only a week and previous experience was working at a sub shop. It was obvious she received some quality training at Casali’s.
The food was very nice. Presentation, Flavor and quality was evident in every course.
We definitely are coming back!
Update 2022: We have been back and our last visit was as good as before. Looking forward to our next!

Just sat down for lunch and welcomed with great service and super friendly faces. Jeff is the man!!! Ask him anything and he can make the best drinks ever.

**Update*** went back today to eat for lunch. Waited an hour for food and then had to get it togo. I understand the circumstances that a business ordered food Togo and then called in and doubled the order which put our order behind and we are in the restaurant. When I got back to work 5mins away the food was cold and bread was hard and it wasn't what I expected. I will have to wait for me next visit. I have to drop my rating from a 5 down to a 3.
I often update my reviews.

The service is fantastic and the atmosphere is comfortable!! The food isn't bad! (I'm spoiled from the Erie Italian restaurants)

Food is off the charts for a small town staff is friendly.... Priced very fair for the portion sizes.... I was so stuffed I didn't have room for desert... So I have to go back for desert soon .... Muscles Diablo and the steak car Alfredo.... I ate so much I almost ate my fingers in the process.... Very legit very very good food

Had lunch today our food was disgusting. Your tartar sauce was vile. There were dead bugs on window ledge and our table. Your saving grace was the chocolate cake you didn’t make. Your restrooms are filthy. Your place was recommended.

I love the place. It's my favorite in St.Mary's. One Monday night there was a party and another group gathering so we had to wait an hour for the food we(2 guests) ordered. They were short on staff so I understand. Otherwise, the service is amazing, food taste delicious and the menu choices is just right.

We were in town visiting family and this place was recommended by several people. They have a variety of food and beverage choices on the menu, and everything we had was good. The waiter talked me into trying their new honey mustard dressing for my salad and I am so glad he did! I kept a little to eat with my sweet potato fries too. Several people at the table got the Jack Daniels BBQ burger and raved about it -- I wish I had ordered it too. The waiter was quite friendly and helpful too. Such a nice experience!

The service was good, but we had to wait for someone to seat us for a few minutes even though there was no wait. The food was really good. The portions were ample. We had the spaghetti and it had 3 big meatballs and lots of pasta. Our server was friendly and did a great job. We would definitely go back when we are in St. Mary's.

We chose this restaurant because of the diverse online menu. It was our anniversary and we were totally delighted with the delicious food and the great service. My husband and I will not hesitate to recommend it. It was the best bruchetta we have ever had. We both loved our ravioli, both portobella and cheese. Try it!

Great service and food and the prices are extremely reasonable.