Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe

What a great experience! I would highly recommend stopping here for coffee and food! I tried one of their coffee flights (with a milk alternative!) And a muffin and it was all 10/10! I can't wait to go back try another flight ;) and a sandwich!

Staff is welcoming, helpful, and efficient. Claudia is our favorite batista, but they all do a great job. All food and drink we've ever purchased here, dine-in or carry-out, have been delicious.

Upscale decor in a quaint Cafe. Located in downtown New Carlisle, OH, Penny Lane is an unexpected treat. The food is excellent and the service was prompt and friendly.

I can't say enough good things about Penny Lane! They're my favorite. The atmosphere is perfect with indoor and outdoor seating and friendly/inviting staff. Prices are reasonable. My go-to is an iced chai and their avacado toast. My Fiancé and I have been dreaming about their avacado toast all week. Never gets old. Their sandwiches are amazing too. If it's your first time and you love coffee get a flight. It really adds to the experience. 10/10 highly recommend. No doubt, they will have you coming back for more! What are you waiting for? Go give them a try!! 🧋 🙃

It just keeps getting better! New artwork on the walls, delicious and new menu items, and they've updated the look a bit with some new furniture. Still as inviting and fun as before. Always a good vibe in here. Love this place and will always be back.

We enjoyed our coffee here very much. If I lived in this town, this would be my favorite place. It reminded me of San Fran or Seattle in the vibes. Such talented baristas as well . Great artwork.

I live in Springfield and I think it's worth the drive....good sandwiches..great muffins..and I like the coffee too. Plus...nice people to serve you. Will be a favorite spot this summer ...drive the Vette and enjoy.

usually come in to eat breakfast and get coffee with my girlfriend. today we came around 3 p.m. we probably sat and waited 15-20 mins for our coffee while we watched 3-4 other orders get handed out. keep in mind, we only ordered 2 drinks this time. i ordered an iced latte, usually they are good but this one was absolutely disgusting and not worth the wait. tasted like straight espresso. the woman who took our order was straight up rude. never had this kind of experience here before, but please do better.

I haven't tried the food yet. Just had my first iced coffee from here. It was good AF. Reading the menu 😋 👌 😍 can't wait to try the food. Clean happy feel good place. Must try!!!

Loyal regulars, but we won't be returning. We've witnessed one too many times start taking about guests & their orders. Trying to involve us in it is uncomfortable.
Complaining about being busy infront of your customers is unwelcoming.
Making fun of my wife's order, not realizing we were together was the final straw.
Really loved this place, but we won't take up anymore of your time.