Search
4.6

100 reviews

Review of Cold Creek Coffee Company

Cold Creek Coffee Company: A Quaint Coffee Shop in Castalia, Ohio

Located in the heart of Castalia, Ohio, Cold Creek Coffee Company is a quaint coffee shop that offers a cozy and peaceful environment for coffee lovers. The shop is housed in a historic building with lots of charm and character, making it a popular spot for locals and tourists alike.

The shop is open from 6:00 am to 6:00 pm from Monday to Friday, and from 6:00 am to 2:00 pm on Saturdays. Unfortunately, the shop is closed on Sundays. The menu is extensive, offering a variety of coffee and tea drinks, including specialty drinks like the iced butterscotch and toasted marshmallow latte, and the Cold Creek mocha frozen. The shop also offers a great selection of pastries that are fresh and moist.

The staff at Cold Creek Coffee Company is friendly and accommodating, always greeting customers cheerfully upon arrival. The service is quick, and the coffee is consistently good. The shop also offers oat and other non-dairy milk options for those who prefer it.

While some customers have noted an unfortunate religious overtone for a coffee shop, which is just odd, most customers have only positive things to say about the shop. Customers appreciate the shop's involvement with the community and the welcoming atmosphere. The shop is also known for its great employees, who are always sweet and accommodating.

If you're looking for a great cup of coffee or tea in a cozy and peaceful environment, Cold Creek Coffee Company is definitely worth a visit.

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Curbside pickup
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Cold Creek Coffee Company Reviews - 100

4.6
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Trace Wilson

Stellar Employees! Great Coffee I would come here again anytime! They have very great employees and I would give them 69 stars on yelp just for that !!!!!!

Aaron Hoff

A beautiful little shop with amazing coffee and tea! Great place for a date, relaxing morning, or casual coffee. Ask about their flights! I loved minešŸ˜

Duane cyr

Great food reasonable prices. Great friendly staff. Great local family restaurant. Some times hardly a wait. Then there are times you will have to wait but not much of a wait. They do a great all you can eat seafood at certain days of the month. You have to call ahead when they do the all you can eat seafood cause they do get very busy.

Jeff Felix

Drove over an hour to try out their seafood buffet. For a fairly rural town, and a uniquely old town feel/decor...this place was awesome! The depth of the seafood selection was astonishing, cooked perfectly, and quality freshness. I hate to admit it, but I got my moneyā€™s worth at the $30 price tag, as well as the family. It seems like they employed half the senior high class that day, but couldnā€™t be more impressed with how hardworking and respectful these young men and women were!! Down to the core of what service means, this may have been the best Iā€™ve ever seen. Menu was reasonably priced, wife had the open faced roast beef, enough for 2 meals. I loved the food, the atmosphere, and the crew. If I could give 6 stars, they earned it.

Suki Skye

They have oat and other non-dairy milk options! Good oat milk lattes, but an unfortunate religious overtone for a coffee shop, which is just odd.

Tracey Harrington

We have enjoyed the monthly bingo night. We drive roughly 45 miles to enjoy their delicious food and friendly wait staff. Big Bang for your bucks. Fresh salad bar!!!! Nice portions. Family friendly

Shelly Roth

Stopped at this place for breakfast on our way home from a trip to Kelley's Island. It was a nice little find. Seemed like a family owned business and the breakfast was delicious. We did made to order and not the breakfast bar, but we were able to go and get our fruit dish from the bar and it was wonderful looking fruit. Price was very reasonable and our waitress was friendly.

Elizabeth Stierhoff

Awesome service. Good coffee drinks, tea and smoothies. They also have good pastries. Some dairy and gluten free one too. Shirts and cups are also available.

Marc Pero

Good food and reasonable prices. Wife had the turkey BLT, and I had the philly cheese tri-tip sandwich. We got the steak fries with both sandwiches, and delicious fresh brewed ice tea. Both sandwiches were tasty, and the fries were good too. We were just passing through and came across the Cafe, and we weren't disappointed.

Ray Reece

Stopped in for lunch today at 2pm not knowing they close at 2, the open light was on. Would not have know that they were trying to close had my wife not asked if the coffee was fresh. The waitress told us that they were technically closed but it was fine. We felt bad and offered to leave but she insisted that it was fine because everyone was there and they were going to reopen at 4pm for buffet. We ordered burgers and our server made a pot of coffee (very good coffee I might add). Our food came out quickly and was very good. What followed is the reason for the poor review. We had an audience of employees(6 or 7 at one point) standing behind the counter watching us eat, (there were still ppl at 2 other tables eating as well) and we could here snide remarks and jokes being cracked at our server about closing time. We ate quickly and left at most 5 minutes after other customers left. The food was great, our server was very good but the atmosphere was poor and shameful.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload