Maggies Magic Muffins

Our first visit to buy some muffins was confusing. We ordered a peach muffin and it had no taste to the muffin itself..ofre in the peaches. The pistachio was an off colored green with a fake pistachio taste. Then they have english walnuts in a pistachio muffin...not pistachios! The muffins were moist, tender and fresh! I don't think we will be going back again!

I got the good vibrations muffin which was delicious! I was overwhelmed by the amount of muffin choices offered. This place is quaint and wonderful.

Hole in the wall type of shop. Had mini muffins for our girls for free, and had an amazing selection of muffins. We got a dozen, 3 breakfast croissant sandwiches and mochas. All delicious. After a few days in the refrigerator the muffins taste so good, and not dry. Be returning back for sure.

These were the best muffins I have had in years. They have the nice homey flavour that big corporations lack. They are huge muffins and they all tasted great! I will definitely be coming back. The ones listed below include: lemon filling, red velvet, chocolate with chocolate chips, blueberry pomegranate, pistachio, and all happy together(has walnuts, chocolate and caramel).

If I could give more than five stars I would.. the lemon blueberry muffin is the best muffin that I have ever had in my life!!

the best muffins in Ohio . hands down.. truly magical

The selection of muffins is amazing. So many different flavors to choose from some I've never heard of. This is a must stop at once in awhile for a great muffin. The owners are very very friendly!

The owner basically told my driver that we would get what she gave them and was very rude AGAIN. That's the second time this has happened and when the driver refers to the owner as vile, that's pretty bad. This place will never get our business again!!!

Haven't had a Maggie's Muffin for years since they are no longer in Austintown. But was near the Boardman location with my mom recently so decided to stop by. Got a half dozen assorted muffins and we weren't disappointed - still delicious! Very moist. So many flavors, you will have a problem choosing a favorite.

If you've ever been here, you know why its 5 stars. If you haven't been here, you absolutely need to. This is my go-to place for gift baskets for any occasion, too. Condolences, congrats, get well, happy wishes... everyone appreciates these muffins and are always something to talk about!