P B & Jay's Café

My husband and I went here the other day for lunch. We love Baked Pie Company so we were excited to try their new sandwich cafe. I got a Peanut Butter and Fig sandwich with Brown Sugar Bacon, which was amazing, and my husband got their Ham and Swiss Quiche, which he really enjoyed. We also got ourselves a little rice crispy treat. We definitely will be coming back, everything is delicious and all the employees were wearing masks, which is a definite plus.

I didn't order anything, I went in to find a full blown breakfast but they offer other options, I did love to see that they offer gluten-free items, their menu looks great, as well as their coffee, and the atmosphere is great. It's very cozy here. The staff are super sweet.

The girl with brown hair is very kind she’s always working around 9am on the weekdays. She’s awesome. Great coffee and it’s so well decorated. Love all the plants in there, super cute. check it out!!

Edit one star. I have a Heath condition and severe asthma. Not everyone can wear a mask. I hope you don’t miss the 6$ coffee plus 3$ tip I give you every morning. I drove out of my way to come to you guys over big chain coffee places. It was embarrassing and the blonde younger lady who yelled at me in front of all those people with that tone was beyond. She let me get all the way to the front of the line after waiting for 10 mins just to chastise me. So you want unmasked folk to stand outside like animal? When no one in town is requiring masks?

Ill never ever be back and I will tell everyone I know to avoid it like the plague. Coffee ain’t even that good anyhow.

Love the concept but not the food. Went for the common peanut butter with strawberry jelly on Wheat berry bread. Bought an oatmeal and raisin cookie too. Wheat berry bread was very dry. Peanut butter was runny and not much flavor. Strawberry jelly was bland. Potatoe chips were good. Was hoping cookie would be wonderful. Nice and thick but hard as a rock. Peanut butter rice crispy treat sample was very good. Wishing it was better. Maybe an off day.

Great place for coffee and to sit outside. The food looked real good but I didn't eat there. Recommend you stop in and give it a try.

We decided to shop at the Garage and were thrilled to see PB & Jay's open. As Inn keepers, we're always curious about treats. So let me tell you, these folks have it going on! We sampled the Espresso Pecan Brownie and let me tell you, these should be illegal they are that good! I decided to have the Apricot Fig Brie and Mushroom Gallette, well forget your manners and lick the plate! Love this place, you have to check it out!

Delicious sandwiches, quiches, beverages and baked goods. The giant chocolate cherry almond biscotti is fantastic!!!

Love this place! Visiting from out of town so we went 2 days in a row and enjoyed everything we ordered. Chai latte was especially good. We will definitely be back next time we're in town.

This place is a great place to get together with friends to chat. The Americano was excellent. The coziness of the couch and nearby chairs were perfect for conversation.

Delicious, reasonably priced, nice vibe, super friendly staff.