P B & Jay's Café

In Feb of 2021 I asked PB & Jay to help me with the purchase and delivery of a gift for a dear friend in the Fayetteville area. I live out of state. Kirsten was absolutely amazing. We communicated mostly by text because of my exceptional schedule at the time. And my friend enjoyed the products, the package was well packed. And Kirsten sent me photos of everything so I could see / feel part of this process. So grateful and highly recommend these folks. Hope to stop by sometime I'm in the area. Thank you PB&Jay and thank you Kirsten!

This local coffee shop and café has a great vibe. Easy to do some work at a table. Good coffee and friendly staff. They even have the “good” ice. IYKYK!

Great food - got a toasted sandwich(apple butter, pecan, sugar bacon) and a lavender latte but there was definitely other things I want to try like the galettes and giant biscotti. The two negatives that dropped a star are the hours (would love Sunday or to be open later a few nights) and I was served on a paper plate with no explanation. I see in the other reviews they have normal plates so an explanation would’ve been fine (oh our dishwasher is broken today)… it just kinda brought the elevated PB&J experience back down to a child’s school lunch.

Pathetic excuse for a PB & J. I ordered cashew butter and apple jam. The bread was cold. There was barely any nut butter or jam. And it was the wrong jam. I had them remake it. The bread was still cold. The jam was still wrong. For a $7 PB&J, are you kidding me? How is it possible to screw up a food item with 3 ingredients?! My 10 year old makes a better sandwich. Rip off.

I loved this place! So cute. I met a friend there for coffee and breakfast. It was my first time in the Cafe, and the staff was so friendly! They explained the whole menu to me, and I didn't feel rushed to just make a choice and order already. The whole menu is cleverly based on PB&J, and all the menu items were reasonably priced from $5-$10. I had an Americano coffee and the Breakfast Banana Split. Both were excellent. Thanks, PB&Jay's. I can't wait to come back and try more of your offerings!

One of the hidden gems of Fletcher. Great atmosphere inside and outside. Excellent location where you can walk a few feet to a playground (Kate’s Park). Quiche and bakery items were delicious. Friendly staff!

It’s the cutest little coffee shop I’ve seen yet, clean, quiet, (despite being next to a daycare/preschool), a library is next door, and the staff are amazing. Just the thing for a boost of happy energy for your day.
Do visit them.

Super cute, quick service, reasonably priced and delicious. I will be coming back!

I have always loved peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. PB&Jay’s are the best I’ve ever had! I have tried most of the menu, and everything is always delicious. 10/10 would recommend!

Very cute spot! Loved the outdoor seating and the order window. I forgot my mask so I was grateful to have a way to order from outside! The pecan butter is AMAZING! So good! So glad to have a spot for coffee and a kid-friendly snack right next to a playground! GENIUS! Thanks!