Sweet Tooth Shop
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
- Same-day delivery
Sweet Tooth Shop Reviews - 100
3.7
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Jackie Cashwell
I have a gluten sensitivity and have been looking for a place that sells gluten free cupcakes. Sweet Tooth offers two kinds, chocolate and red velvet. I must say they are absolutely delicious!!! I am so happy there is someone close by that I can stop in and get a tasty cupcake from. Thanks Sweet Tooth!!
MV W
Great! We stopped for cupcakes this afternoon, and this place was definitely turning over customers! We found the inside to be Kid / family friendly with good seating and water fountains, and a fun window kids can look through into the kitchen.
They had at least a dozen flavor options, appealing to both kids and adults taste. Also noted there were several gluten free flavor options.
Price for basic cupcake $2.79; gluten free $3.00. There is about $1.50 savings for buying a half dozen (which is what we did!).
Cheressa Hollingsworth
So let me start by saying I’m giving this restaurant or two because Of the customer service not to taste. When I got there my cake was not correct And did not display the picture I requested in the email. I also had to leave without a top for my cake. So my cake was all the way open and exposed to everything. Thus, my cake dried out very fast. I expected better since I paid over $50 for a cake so small.
Jenelle Thompson
I recently ordered 2 dozen cupcakes for a bachelorette party and I will say that they were all delicious! They did the design almost exactly as I wanted and they were ready for me to pick up when I came in.
Now the negatives about my experience was that I ordered 4 different flavors for the cupcakes and was told that they were able to accommodate me. However, at 6 a.m. of the day that I was supposed to pick up my order, I was called and they said that they never got the shipment for one of my flavors and that they couldn't make those cupcakes. It was explained to me that I could pick two other flavors instead to replace it. I decided to do half and half but was promptly called back again just to say they didn't have the substitute flavor either.
This did upset me because they should've known when their shipment would arrive and tell me in advance instead of springing it on me the morning of pickup day. It felt as if they did that on purpose so that I wouldn't cancel my order and ask for my partial payment back which is exactly what I would've done because I needed all those flavors for the bride as they were her favorite.
Also, telling me that I could pick a substitute flavor just to call back and say that it wasn't available either seemed a bit ridiculous. I would expect for you to know for sure since you are giving me bad news and trying to make it better.
All in all my experience with Sweet Tooth Shop was okay customer service wise but the cupcakes were delicious.
Phillip Graves
I've had Georgetown Cupcakes and when I did I understood why people thought they were so special. I ended up buying some for a few people in my office and ordering dozens to be shipped as Valentines Day and Mother's Day presents. They are by no means run of the mill cupcakes.
I didn't think they could be rivaled, especially not by a local baker.
Sweet Tooth absolutely matches Georgetown in terms of quality and even beats them on Taste with a few of their flavors. The prices is as expected.
If you just want a cupcake for sake of having one, elsewhere would be a better option.
If you want an indulgence that you will brag about to someone, only wishing you could offer them the experience of eating one as you describe it, then you owe your soul a visit.
D
Today I experienced a very strong craving for a macaron. I usually purchase them from Amitié Macaron, and I highly recommend them. Having said that, sometimes it is hard to get them from there. This resulted in me requesting my boyfriend to get a macaron from this patisserie near him , as current reviews suggest that they are of a great quality. The previous statement could not be further from the truth. The product that they make is not consistent with an authentic macaron. It would be more appropriately listed as two fairly hard cookies with a marshmallow like substance in the middle. If you find yourself in a similar position , craving an authentic macaron, I recommend searching for different options. If you like the taste of mediocre, and incorrectly advertised bakery items this is your place ! L’horreur!
P.S. I am only giving two stars because the lemon flavor itself was good . I purchased lemon and vanilla.
Debbie Soto
My family and I love this place. We have ordered a wedding cake and several birthday cakes and they have all been delicious! For the wedding cake we wanted sugar flowers and they advised us to order them because it would be way more expensive if they made them. We did and they set up the cake and added the flowers at no extra charge (there were a lot of flowers).
Susan Richardson
Omg! I had sweet tooth to make my nephew a Sesame Street designed birthday cake and they did an excellent job!! They made my nephews 1st birthday so special. My family and friends complimented on how well the cake was designed and how good it taste. Through this difficult time because of the pandemic, sweet tooth bakery made myself and my families special day more beautiful! I could almost cry and really don’t know how many ways to say thank you Sweet Tooth of Fayetteville!!
You’re the best and will forever have me and my entire family as customers. To anyone reading this just know you will not be disappointed with their service.
Nahir Sanchez
I liked that they where nice, very clean. I got a couple of cupcakes for my friends birthday but the cupcakes where super dry and they had a lot of frosting. We end up throwing them away after one bite. I lost 46 dollars. I'm only giving three stars because the staff was super nice, other than that I'm not buying again from here.
Pavlo Stetsko
I bought a cake for my sisters baby shower and I loved it! I only bought a One tiered cake (b/c of the price) but it was definitely bigger than I expected. The lines were clean and the cake tasted great. Will be going with them from now on and is definitely worth the price.