Sweet Tooth Shop

We always go to this shop. Their icing is never too sweet and their cakes are so moist and soft! My sister ordered a custom cake for our baby shower in 2020 and it did NOT disappoint. The flavors in the cake were amazing and all of our guests loved it. Their cheesecake and cupcakes are my go to desserts here. My favorite bakery in Fayetteville hands down.

I would love to share my experience. For the price honestly I would just go to Small cakes. I went and bought 6 it cost me almost $30. And they were way way smaller than what you can get at small cakes for. The red velvet ones were not that great either. I was really excited but it was a real let down. We just moved here and wanted to try something new. The cupcakes were just so small for the price. If I would of known I would of gone to small cakes. I also don’t like that they kind of guilt trip you to tip they turn the whole iPad. We are purchasing items not being served or attended they should make more instead of asking customers to pay their wages 🥲 I feel bad because the ladies were so kind it’s just the whole experience was super expensive!

Great bakery and they get vegan orders correct! All of the vegan cupcakes that I have received are amazing. I don’t have to worry about getting sick here at all. Also try their brownies! If they’re out of a flavor they actually call and let me know, good folks. Thanks for making my life easier. My wife says that the ice cream is also very tasty.

This stuff is addicting!

No need to wax poetic about consistency, flavor, creaminess...this stuff is delicious...period! Miss out if you want to, more for me!

Got a cupcake and was Not impressed at all! Very tiny to be over $3.19. The icing was pretty nasty and the cake was hard and has no flavor. Drive a couple miles to the cupcake shop near Subway on Skibo. 🤢

I am so happy that I found this place tonight! Not only were the cupcakes absolutely delicious, but the donut my husband got was so dang good. That raspberry filling omg. I was so excited to find out there are vegan options here because my son has a dairy allergy and I’m so excited that we have a cute little spot to go for our cupcakes! The girl working was very attentive and sweet! Reasonable prices and so much to choose from! We will certainly be back!

I walked in and I was so excited and overwhelmed with all the delicious sweets everywhere. I went twice in one week (I shouldn't have)
The macaroons were amazing
Cheese cake- omg I got strawberry, turtle Carmel,
Plan cheese cake and a sugar free
Ice cream- crazy vanilla flavor for my daughter
I have to say all was super delicious! My family and I enjoyed it and I recommend for you and your family to give it a try!

The Sweet Tooth is the best bakery in this area! I often take cupcakes to work for staff. The bakery individually packages the cupcakes to assist with safety precautions. Staff are always satisfied.

I placed my order from Georgia to announce a pregnancy; the experience was beyond what could have been expected for a last-minute purchase. The customer service well exceeded 5 stars!!

My girls and I went here today for the first time, originally for just macaroons. We ended up get other stuff as well. Unfortunately, it will be our last. There was a very small selection of baked goods to choose from. Less than half the menu, was available. We bought cup cakes, macaroons and cake pops. All of the cake products we bought today tasted old and very dry. This is the first time I have ever had macaroons, so I can't say what they should taste like, but I can only imagine what fresh ones would taste like. These were definitely not fresh. The customer service was not that great either, the person who rang us up, seemed annoyed and unhappy. She wasn't rude, but very unwelcoming. All in all, I was extremely disappointed with this bakery. Maybe week days are better, but do not go here on a weekend.