L'Italia

Food, service and atmosphere is wonderful. The prices are just too high for the portion sizes you get. I'd love to go here more often, but it's just not reasonable.

We are so glad to have found excellent Italian food at reasonable prices, with wonderful, friendly service, right here in Wellsville! Neither veggies nor shrimp were overcooked-- both perfect and tender. The sauces were delicious, and the salmon moist, not dry. Interesting coctails from the bar, a decent wine list featuring some Finger Lakes wines, and about the best Tiramisu we've eaten anywhere! We had been looking for a local place to take guests to dinner when we have visitors... and we have found it in L'Italia! Also great for our own casual date nights, or to meet a friend for lunch.

Delicious experience at L'Italia tonight. Server was friendly and attentive, even though the restaurant was busy. Appetizer special was delicious and unique. Entrees arrived timely and each one was incredible. Sauces all packed with flavor and shrimp/steaks/pasta perfectly cooked. Highly recommend and will return!

We love it here and have been going since forever with family and friends! It's fancy enough for a date but casual enough to not be stuffy. The pizza is delicious and different--my sister and I always split a large Bella (pictured here) and have a couple leftover slices to fight over the next day!

Stopped in yesterday with a large group after my nieces graduation. We were sat promptly and our server was awesome. She was super attentive and ensured that we were all taken care of. The food was well made and delicious.

Was seeking a nice place for diner in the area where my daughter is going to college and found L'Italia. Really cool section of town, old style feel with a hip vibe. Food was excellent, the wife and I both ordered Salmon dishes and it was perfect. Prices are reasonable. Will go again for sure, a lot of variety on the menu.

Good place to eat. I like it there. The owners are a great young couple. Very personable, very nice. I like them both very much. All the staff is great too. The waitresses are great too. I have never met the Cooks, but the food is good so I will just give the Cooks props for that. At least once a week we have a meal here. Mostly takeout, but tonight was a delight because we actually dined in the restaurant and it made me remember again just how much I like it there. Stop in and enjoy!

Great comforting food. Very nice atmosphere. Amazing for Wellsville. The waiter was very nice & generous. Wellsville has a very nice main street with fun shops, eateries, & nice local folk.

We had a wonderful experience! The customer service was great. Simon was our server and he had a great attitude. Everyone worked as a team and made sure we were taken care of. The food was hot and fresh. We left there very full and with leftovers.

For me, dining is in the details. I had a Greek salad with Shrimp. Iceberg lettuce with a few pieces of green leaf tossed in, and the shrimp was plain, thawed jumbo. The dressing came in a plastic cup. Here's what I would have expected from an establishment trying to sell itself as somewhat upscale -- mixed greens (preferably from one of the many farms in this region), lightly seasoned & seared shrimp, and a reusable dressing vessel rather than wasteful single-use plastic. The staff was friendly, but it was slow & the floor could have used a sweeping. There were crumbs under most tables.