Southold General

Started off with a bang. Now a whimper. Two months ago you could count on four or more behind the counter on Sunday AM, now only two and one had to ask the other where everything was. Cashier now making coffee, training worker and running register.
Hours frequently not as posted. They close when they feel like it.
Pizza looks good but soggy and poor tasting.
If you want butter for French toast you have to ask at least three times.
All food served in hard to open cardboard boxes. Counter trash hole not big enough to stuff used boxes down.
Coffee either so hot it burns your lips or so tepid you want to send it back.
Door to patio opens frequently letting blasts of cold air into dining area.
Chairs like sitting on a rock.
Tables not cleaned after diners leave.
They have obviously spent a couple million on designing and building this place. They should all go back to school.
Does not appear to be any management whatsoever.
Have made three visits. Will not return.

The pastries are truly fantastic. We always get an almond croissant and a pain au chocolat to split. Also tried the breakfast sandwiches this past visit and the home made muffins really are the killer ingredient.

Beautiful storefront and outdoor seating. I had a latte, almond croissant and formaggi pizza. Pizza slice was delicious and latte was out of this world! Almond croissant could have been better but maybe I should try it fresh out of the oven? Prices are a bit exorbitant for sandwiches ($22). Overall, I would visit here again!

We heard great things about this place so we decided to take a leisurely 45 minute drive to have a quiet lunch without the kiddos. Arrived at 1:50pm on labor day weekend to find out that they were out of food. We couldn't even believe it. With the inflated prices the owners should be able to over order food without cutting into profits too heavily. We left disappointed and vowed never to return. Save your money and time and skip it!

I love the community vibe, it’s nice to have new spot in town to grab coffee. It’s bright and airy, has great energy. The staff is excellent, Jess makes the best coffee! Everyone who works there is super friendly and professional and always has a smile on their face. Overall I really love this place and go here pretty much every day. Highly recommend!

excellent cafe - great selection- friendly staff - a bit expensive but delicious food here. thank you SG. so happy you arrived 🙌

Five bucks coffee and small sourdough sandwiches say it all. Oh, I forgot to mention a huge bucket upfront the counter for tips! Definitely above my needs....

Want to love this place but so far not... Salads are not mixed, bland and mostly uncut lettuce. Hard to eat with synthetic cutlery from a plastic container. Sandwiches are massive, all have mayo and they're not particularly good and $20+. I'd pay $20 for a sandwich but for that I want it on a plate and and made on the spot. Pizza is soggy.

Went for Gelato on a Saturday night. They were out of chocolate. They're often out of things.

Been 5 times and not 1 great experience. Yesterday may have been my last when they were out of the 3 things I wanted...true story and confused my order.

Oh..and no recycling for those that care about the planet..?

First time there and was really pleased 😀 We met the manager who was very friendly and welcoming. I had guests coming to my home so I purchased a dessert to take home. WOW! It was delicious and everyone raved about it. I will definitely be back.

There's no way a counter serve joint can charge between $25-37 for a sandwich. You can get a counter-serve sandwich down the road for half that price. Even a lobster roll you can get almost anywhere for $25-30 instead of the almost $40 they charge here. We got pizza and our pizza was lukewarm and my parents' slices were soggy. Can't justify spending the amount they charge for microwaved food when you can get better food at Applebee's.