Southold General

OMG - just cut into the “extra” pumpkin pie I bought for Thanksgiving. It is the best pumpkin pie I have ever tasted. Have never been a huge fan of pumpkin pie because it is often dense. But, this is light, airy, and spectacular. Wowsers. Cannot wait to taste the apple crumble tomorrow!!

Pretty good. Had the KK’s salad (had to cut it up and mix it together, but no bother here... Just how I like my salad). Produce seems fresh; I think the salad was fairly priced assuming the veggies came from KK’s down the street.

Grabbed a chicken sandwich for my boyfriend, and when I got it to him he noticed that there was a produce sticker on the tomato... This I am not happy about. For $22 I expect a certain level of quality, and part of this is the kitchen prep.

I don't mind paying for high-quality food, but please make sure that the product you are serving is reflective of this.
Overall, average experience.

NIcely curated place! Bright and airy with a variety food and beverages. The pizza looks very good in the showcase, but does not taste good at all: soggy, runny sauce... A bit overpriced on all products...

I love this place. Great food, service with a smile always. The pastries are a must and the coffee is amazing. Great destination!!

Great addition to Southold Town. That Turkey Sammy 🤌🏼🤌🏼🤌🏼 Coffee is on point, pizzas are amazing and pastries 10/10.

Loved the outdoor space. Was reading a lot of reviews about the price here and I usually don’t mention it but we got two sandwiches, Two coffees and two bottles of water and the bill was $65. Definitely worth going but maybe once a month since it is a little pricey. Also make sure you get there before 11am to be able to get breakfast. It doesn’t matter if you were on the line before 11am. They will not serve breakfast if you haven’t ordered at the register before 11am.

Everything I've tasted here has been superior. You can tell someone knows what they're doing when even the crust on a fruit tart is soft, buttery, flaky, and delectable. I particularly like the quiche, pizza, and pastries. My husband likes the tuna and mozzerella sandwiches, and the prices seems to have fallen into line also. Drinks are delicious, too.

This place was promising given its lovely presentation but ultimately was not worth the price. The mocha latte was not properly mixed (chocolate sediment not melted), and the sandwich was exceptionally dry. The breakfast sandwich was pre-made beforehand a-La Starbucks but was not reheated well as the egg was cold in center. Place is also extremely loud and echoes (was too hot to sit outdoors). There is a reason I mention Starbucks, bc that’s basically what this place is: a Starbucks cosplaying as a local coffee shop. This place does have some decent pastry which is only reason I didn’t rate it one star. Honestly, North Fork Roast up the street is much better & where I’d recommend folks go. This place belongs in Brooklyn, not Southold.

We found this place while walking around the town and we were excited to find it. We ordered 2 sandwiches, which were good.
We ordered a 12oz can of coke and were shocked to see the price. 5.75 for a can of coke. Where do they come off charging that. You can buy 5 -2 liters bottles for that price. It’s a shame, because the food was good and the place was nice. We drove an hour to get there.

Nice looking food and a welcome addition to the area but almost $4 for a small coffee? I understand you’re catering to the new city residents that recently discovered the NF, but come on. Take it down a notch and I’ll come back.