Grindstone Coffee & Donuts

Donuts are overpriced. We were the only customers to say please and thank you and not cut the line and the staff was beyond rude acting like they were doing us a favor by helping us. They all looked bored and unhappy to be there. Welcome to the Hamptons. #Hooplah

Sounds good but girl at the register is just way too snooty, the brunette girl. Donuts and coffee are good but come on what’s with the attitude we all use part with the same money

I always want to like Grindstone because it has so much potential. The overall design of the place itself is so nice and they have a great location. I personally just don’t think the doughnuts are very good. They are dry and lacking in flavor.

Great donuts but very sugary

Grindstone is a must stop in Sag Harbor Village. From their amazing staff to delicious creative donuts and the best coffee in the Hamptons, be sure not to miss it! You won’t be disappointed.

Follow up: After receiving the response from the owner of Grindstone to my review below, I need to clarify that our visit was on Tuesday, June 26th and we were the only customers in the shop which couldn't have been "the singe busiest day of the year". I agree taste is definitely subjective. I suppose quality for price could also be subjective. I live in Westchester County which is just as expensive as Sag Harbor and I have certain quality and service expectations that simply weren't met. I also agree that everyone deserves a second chance so if we are ever in Sag Harbor again we will stop in again. Thank you for your response to my review.

Wow, really disappointed. I was told they had the best donuts I would ever eat in my life. I really should have managed my expectations better. Really expensive and my classic donut was just plain inedible. My daughter and her friend, 10 and 11 years old, were unimpressed as well. The place was clean, we felt like we were interrupting the day of the people who worked there. I guess I have to remember I was in Sag Harbor but I feel like that shouldn't be an excuse.

I ran in here for a quick coffee and a donut. not my favorite choice of donut. but it was good.very cool interior. the iced coffee that I had was really good, great flavor

Lots of competition with coffee shops out here... Sag Town use to have the best..however Grindstone might now be King!! Best Hot Chocolate i’ve ever had!!! The donuts will make you go nuts!! Atmosphere is great wish they had a bigger store however the location can’t be beat. A++

Traveled from Manorville to see what all the hype was about. Honestly, I was very dissappointed in the taste and texture of the doughnuts I purchased. Besides the high price, they were dry, and tasteless. Lovely area, but, wont be going to Grindstone again.

Sleeping baby in the car and wouldn’t meet me at the door to give me the order. Was just shocked.