Bagelicious of Bayberry

This is not the place to ho for a real bagel. These bagels are not made on site and they are more like dinner rolls with flavoring on top. I ordered an everything bagel which was light and fluffy not chewy and dense like a bagel should be. The strawberry creme cheese was so sweet I could not eat it. Im guessing its a low quality creme cheese. Never will I go there again.

Excellent bagels - absolutely fresh and delicious. I tried the garlic, onion, spinach/parm. My wife had the plain, egg, and chocolate chip so far. All were amazing!!! Many cream cheese spread flavors to choose from.

Great staff, great breakfast options!

Very friendly staff, great bagels fresh everyday, good sandwiches prices are good!! They have wagmans & dunkin donuts beat much better 🥯 bagels best bagels around!!! I highly recommend it

I love bagels. Always have! This place makes amazing cream cheeses. You gotta base bagel places based off of how good their CC tastes. And I love that they have egg bagels. I received a platter for the holidays and this is how cute it looks! I've been there in person before and the staff is very friendly. The wait may be long but that's how it is in bagel places I've experienced in my past.

What an amazing place!! The bagels are so delicious. And they serve Kubal coffee!! Home fries were so good as well. They have a breakfast and lunch menu. So glad I stopped in!! And will many more times after!!

Awesome Bagels. They prepare them authentically Soft and chewy outside. And they don't get stale after a couple of days like certain competitors. I seen one review that was a 1 and it was laughable. Sometime there is a wait but that is because they are usually busy and that is the best sign for how good they are. The breakfast sandwich is cooked right there on a skillet. Freshness that you don't get often.

I think I would of gave 5 stars if the order was actually correct because the bagels seemed good. It took almost 5 mins for the lady to take order of one bagel cream cheese and one sesame bagel butter AND it was STILL wrong.. the people were very very nice and although it was really busy the orders came out pretty quick. I couldn't judge the bagel fairly cause i don't eat cream cheese but they were toasted perfectly and the flavor of bagel was nice... Overall good bagel selection nice place to sit and very friendly staff. Wish attention to orders would be better but I will definitely be back.

My wife and I were so excited to try a locally made breakfast. We choose to eat a certain way, and were looking so forward to a semi-healthy "cheat" bagel sandwich. Unfortunately, they were somehow out of pumpernickel bagels at 9:30am. We were so disappointed, that how good the bagels actually are, didn't matter. We are sure that when they have them, the food is fantastic. We will never know because we won't stop there hoping they have bagels. It's a bagel place....have bagels.

Hands down THE BEST bagels. Prices are great, food is delicious.