Collegetown Bagels

The best lunch if you are in Ithaca. Tasty bagel sandwiches and a nice selection of sweets.

Such a cool place. The food is delicious and very unique. They have live music playing often. I like the rotating menu of different coffee drinks. I also order from the salad bar often, there's always different things in there. I am a vegetarian and they have lots of options for me.

Nice local spot to grab a smoothie, bagel sandwich, coffee, and maybe some ice cream. Everything here is good, but not spectacular. I strongly recommend the rosemary salt bagel. It is doughy perfection. The interior is cozy, and definitely feels like Ithaca.

The food is just ok. The sandwiches I've gotten are small for the price and not particularly well made. The iced teas are good, pretty similar to what you'd get at Starbucks. I think this place relies on image more than actually making good food. This is a good place to get some work done and they're open late so that's cool!

Not sure why there are so many great reviews. Their bagel sandwiches are underwhelming and just ok. Their set up for ordering coffee and sandwiches makes little sense. Coffee was mediocre and took forever. Long story short, not worth it.

A regular meeting place for me and my friends to get coffee and breakfast. Service is friendly, fast, and accurate. They play good music and they have PURITY'S ICE CREAM!

I Love their pizza bagels and Sweet Rachel sandwiches.

Great breakfast and sandwich joint. Often busy but they're somewhat quick getting you through the line. Seating inside isn't great but they offer outside seating as well. Food is amazing, and really a necessary visit if you're in Ithaca.

Don’t expect an easy ordering process. We got lost inside trying to order at the right counter. Sandwiches were extremely oily, chicken was cold, and the brownie tasted stale. Waste of money. Will not be coming back.

Yummy Long Island lox. There was an error on our receipt and we were undercharged. Let the cashier know and the manager was very kind to comp us one of our sandwiches, even though we insisted it wasn’t necessary

Always a delicious choice when visiting Ithaca! I make sure to visit every time I’m in town.