Buttercrumbs Bakery

This bakery is amazing and everything there is slightly unique. They have fantastic soups n sandwiches for lunch, and of course the baked goodies are phenomenal. It's obvious that the owners love what they do because they're so generous and are willing to take on fun personalized projects. I recommend this place.

I stopped in to pick up some cinnamon rolls and stood at the counter for awhile as one employee took care of a customer at the register while another younger employee just stood there not even acknowledging me. Very frustrating.
Finally the first employee finished with her customer and was able to help me. I requested some cinnamon rolls, and I was asked if I called in advance.
I said no and from that point there seemed to be some kind of snarkiness attitude from the lady helping me that caught me off guard.
In the end they served me some cinnamon rolls and we took them home where we enjoyed them.
Fortunately I'm not sure what the deal was with the employees working there that morning but I guess everyone has an off day.
I would still recommend the Butter Crumb for their delicious pastries.

I found this place on line and was out for a motorcycle ride with friends, stopped for lunch and was throughly happy!!! Amazing selection of sweets in the case and a great lunch menu. Had soup and sandwich. Service/staff all very nice and the place is a sheer delight! will make a point of returning!

What a cute and quaint bakery. My favorite is their brownies. Yum! The staff is very friendly and their products are excellent. They have too many choices for my taste though, but only because I'm so indecisive. It can be dangerous to your wallet and waistline walking into Buttercrumbs, but do it anyway! You won't regret it.

Loved my visit there (July 2019) - I'm from Montreal (Canada)… This place is sooo charming! My family and I loved the 'chocolat Zucchini bread' as well as the cookies & biscottis. I also enjoyed a cold Chai Latte. I will go back as soon as I can! :)

We stopped on our way home from Buffalo. Got paninis, some pastry & apple pie. Paninis were delicious & pie is wonderful, flaky crust & great apple filling. We will be back, just wish you were closer to Warsaw! 😍

Delicious panini for lunch. Great selection of hit tea and, of course, a wide array of freshly baked cookies, pies, cakes, etc. Pleasant small eating area or you can order to go. Definitely will return.

We really miss the original owners - something was lost when they left. Still, the new owners have carried on the vision. Good selection of baked goods and featuring Caribou Coffee, now hard to find on the East coast.

Oh man, that Reuben was so good!!!!

Great coffee, wonderful local people. I didn't get a scone, but they looked heavenly!!

Also they make doggy donuts and my bloodhound loved it!!!

Always enjoy the food and the friendly staff. A treat every time! Also their coffee is tasty, pairing nicely with the wonderful pastry creations!