The Coffee Potter

I was 'backed up' when I came here to get a frozen chai tea latte with my girlfriend. About 10 minutes after we drank them, we were both scrambling to relieve ourselves in the bathroom...Relieve may be a soft word, considering I may have cracked the toilet bowl. It was totally worth it. It tasted great and got rid of my constipation. I'm only giving it 4 stars because the girl taking orders had some politically biased shirt on. Not here in the morning for politics, just coffee..wear a shirt that pertains to the establishment. Overall, great experience!

Amazing coffee! We will definitely be back!! Good customer service and very helpful. All of us at Dalcourt's Desserts really loved your Signature Blend Coffee.

Super cute coffee place. Beyond great service and the best coffee!

Not only the BEST coffee around, but the best people ! From the owners, Geralyn and Dave to every single staff member, everyone is so beyond nice ! Such a warm and cozy atmosphere where I felt like family from day 1 and made some very amazing friends !! Guaranteed 5 star experience every single time !!

First off, I love the name!!! Who wouldn't?! Anyway, I decided to stop one day on my way home. I got a medium Vanilla Latte (I know, basic, right?) and I wait till I get home since I've got to drive over (steeply) curved roads. I get home in 20 minutes and as I take the stopper out, I smell the most heavenly scent. I sip, not too hot and not the least bit cold...perfect temperature. I start to drink and I'm thinking, "Wow, this is good." By the time I was done, I quickly went from 'good' to 'great'. Keep it up, Coffee Potter, you just end up with regular customer!!!

I debated posting this. But Pattie beat me to it. My daughter and I were getting coffee today and were walking in as all of the commotion was going on. For starters the tow truck was not in the wrong and he was doing his job. The owner came out and started screaming and yelling at the gentleman loading the car. You would think that the owner would want to get the car towed out so it wasn’t blocking anymore. They are emergency vehicles? And there was hardly any traffic that was on Schooleys mountain road which was really just a few cars and a truck. The driver was doing his job and the owner was just out of line. I feel bad for the girl with the car being towed as well because she looked mortified. I watched the whole thing happen and the owner was calling the driver some very disrespectful names and the drive just retaliated as the guy inched closer to him. After this was all over the owner still carried on in side. As much as I wanted to like the coffee it wasn’t as good as I thought. And my daughters was not what she asked for will not be coming here again. I wouldn’t reccomend.

The coffee is always good. The crumb cake is awesome! And the staff is always welcoming, efficient and quick.

One of my favorite small town local coffee shop destinations when out on the motorbike! They have just enough parking for walk in traffic but on a busy saturday you might be hardpressed to fit in. The friendly baristas make a wonderfull cuppa!

Great place!! Coffee, tea, hot chocolate, and so much more! Tasty baked goods! Friendly staff!!

Just happened to be in Long Valley visiting a friend when she suggested going to the Coffee Potter for an iced chai tea latte. WOW! So good that I went back this morning for a hot Matcha latte with oat milk. It did not disappoint! The drive thru (yes~a drive thru!!) was about 4 cars deep when I arrived, but the young lady taking carside orders was friendly and efficient. My wait was no longer than 7 minutes on a busy Sunday morning. I can't wait to go back!