Old Town Cafe

Service was fast, and staff were friendly. Unfortunately what we had was overpriced (no surprise for the location) but mediocre. Roast beef and gravy were very salty. Salad was basic lettuce out of a bag with croutons, with a lot of the lettuce wilted. Fish was so-so, fries were fine but salty.

If I could give this restaurant a 0 star, I would. They brought us dirty glasses to the table. One of them had lipstick stain on it. I told them right away, and forgot to take a picture. Restrooms had a strong smell, looks like they don’t clean them often. Food was flavorless. Our Server was rude. I honestly don’t understand how this restaurant has so many good reviews. I don’t recommend anyone to come to this place.

We might have been in town during a busy time, but we bounced around restaurant to restaurant, and they all had lines out the door/ long wait times. Why Old Town Cafe didn't, I'm sure I don't know. We walked in, got a table, and had a fantastic experience. Brock took care of us. We had the pot roast, and a huckleberry beer. 10/10 would go back.

Had a cheeseburger, hot beef sandwich, French dip, and a grilled cheese. All was hot and delicious! Fresh cut fries were crispy and yummy. We were seated right away and our waitress was good. Was $60ish for 4 meals and 3 sodas. Not bad for a great meal! Would eat here again.

Our family of four arrived just as the place opened.

We were welcomed with warm smiles and plenty of cheer :)

I ordered two eggs, buscuits & gravy, hashbrowns, and one apple cinnamon pancake.

Needless to say my meal was a large portion and very hearty!

All of our meals were well-served and more than filling andndndnd enjoyable for a about $13 +/-.

Will we return: YES!

Buffalo patty and flap Jack you can go wrong delicious.

Wonderful atmosphere, great service and very good food!!

Great food and if you want a buffalo burgers 🍔 best in town. Very friendly and nice atmosphere.

Service is good but not the food. We ordered medium-rare steak, it came as well-done. We ordered burger, and it had no flavor

This is the second trip to Yellowstone. We had found this restaurant on our first trip and we were so happy to see it was still there and open. The food there is soooooo good and reasonably priced. We had three meals there: two breakfasts and one special dinner before traveling on. The staff is so friendly and efficient. The owners are as friendly and efficient as the staff. I would give ten stars if possible. I wish that this restaurant was here in Florida.