Creighton's Crazy Egg Cafe & Coffee Bar

OUTSTANDING! Being a farm girl, this brought back many childhood memories. Wonderful waitress and delicious breakfast. Planning on going again next week. Highly recommend.

Good coffee, not great but good. Service was a bit slow and they just didn't seem like they were interested in going any faster. I would probably come here again as I think it deserves another shot. The interior decor is unique and had that vintage feel to it. Some of the housewares and other items they sell are interesting. Not my thing, but I can see the appeal.

Busy place; always a good sign. Worth the wait if you hit them during peak times. We've been here twice and have been extremely pleased with the food and service. Cracker Barrel atmosphere but without the franchise feel. Fresh farm to table food is tops! Omelettes are light and fluffy, (loved the 3-cheese one I had!). The Scotch Eggs are some of the best I've ever had. Be adventurous and try the deviled Scotch Eggs, wonderful wonderful wonderful!! Friendly wait-staff that cares about your experience with them. High recommendation!!

This is an admittedly biased review. I have celiac disease, and this used to be one of my favorite breakfast spots for saturdays (one of the few regarded as safe for people with gluten sensitivities to have a good breakfast in warsaw area). problem is, a buffet only environment
is a big no no for anyone with food sensitivities. regardless of safeguards and precautions taken before the food hits expo, it is essentially undone as one must rely on every individual guest not to cross contaminate the food at the buffet line. not a risk some can take. bummer. used to love this place.

Beautiful place to eat and great food! They also got a coffee bar and little gift shop!

Wondered into this place unawares of the treat it would be! Atmosphere, food and staff are superb; casual, delicious and friendly, respectively. We first visited for breakfast on Friday and returned Sat for breakfast. We were a bit sad that Sat was buffet only because we had our hearts set on the crispy chicken and waffle breakfast available from the menu only. But we were delighted with the service and food once again. We may return before our stay in Winona Lake comes to an end.

Great food but you will get a long wait, for sure. I come back for the half order of Creightons style Eggs Benedict. The coffee bar has some good options but we’ve never had success at orders coming out correctly. The last time we were there the waitress seemed to forget our table so I went and got the drinks we ordered myself and dealt with the coffee bar staff when the orders weren’t right. The busyness makes it feel a little chaotic sometimes and the waits are always long to get in and to get food. It’s worth the try for the food tho.

Nice place clean and service was fast the food was yummy this is a must see try it you will like it

I love this place! The coffee bar is so cute and the iced coffee and waffle were really good!

Excellent food and service in a cool farmhouse setting!