Wild West Home of Mamma Italia

service was really good, everyone made you feel really comfortable. the food was also very yummy.

If you're interested in breakfast, make sure you ask how old any of the various display items are. I once decided to order the quiche, and what came back to me was obviously 3 or 4 days old... the crust was rock-hard, the edges of the slice were devoid of moisture as if it had been sitting out in the open for days and was all wrinkled down and tough at the edges. The next time I went in, I asked ahead of time how many days the quiche had been out. Points for honesty: three days. Gross.

Next, lunch. I once ordered a Turkey Club to go. What I got was a turkey sandwich. I accepted it as a one-off mistake, and the next time I went in for lunch I ordered the Turkey Club again, specifically making sure they understood I wanted the "club" not the regular "sandwich". Again, received a turkey sandwich. FYI: a "club" has three pieces of bread, top and bottom toasted with a layer in the middle, and all the fix'ns stacked inside. They have a "club" and a "sandwich" on their menu... makes me wonder what the heck they're serving as a "sandwich."

Want fries with that? Pay an extra $2.50 and you'll get 6 or 7 limp fries that are partially un-cooked in the middle. Fry sauce is really good though... you'll need it.

I once wrote an email to the owner, Naomi, complaining about the quality of the food I was receiving. Big points for her when she offered me a free lunch. All points wiped away when I ordered a turkey club and got a turkey sandwich-- this time the bottom slice of bread was so soggy with moisture that it was virtually inedible. I threw it away.

I've given this place so many chances, and have yet to experience anything good about it.

Interesting to learn that the menu changes completely from burgers and sandwiches to an Italian menu in the evening. No matter...the food was still good! Service was almost over-attentive. We didn't need a waitress visit every few minutes. 😄

Food was good, staff was friendly and the atmosphere was welcoming! They have a full coffee bar (the most important food group!). First time here but will definitely be back!

The food was good but the service was a little slow. They did cater to my one year old really well and brought me little extras for him. Love he outdoor seating and the servers are all very nice, they just aren't in a hurry and seem a little inexperienced.

The address on Google Maps is wrong, its not 5928, its 83 E State St. We went there for lunch. Ruben was very average, and it was $11.50, not $9.50 as listed in the online menu. They list fish tacos on their menu, but they don't serve tacos anymore. The service was slower than molases and they messes up my friends order. The $1.75 can of Diet Coke was a nice touch. Not horrible, but also nothing to come back for.

Had dinner tonight at the NEW Wild West. Had heard good things about the new owners and their Italian dinner on Friday and Saturday nights. We booked a table for six tonight and found it very busy when we arrived. Johnny, the owner, was very knowledgeable about the wines that they served and helped us choose the perfect wine for a meal. The appetizers were fantastic. As a matter fact, my friend mentioned that his selection was “life-changing” and one of the best things he had ever tasted. Turned out we all ordered something different for our entree. My gnocchi was absolutely spot on. Everyone thought their meal was delicious.

We then met Lena who makes all of the desserts. I have traaveled extensively through Italy, and the tiramisu was the best I have ever tasted, bar none. Said with regret to the Nona who made it up in norther Italy. Lena has hers beat!

Dominico was helpful and informative and generally lovely to talk to.

Friends, this is a family-owned business. And I mean family owned! The food is all fresh and House made. The menu has a good selection. Everything is made with love and care. This is a tiny hole in the wall Italian eatery that is not to be missed. Granted, another Italian restaurant in Eagle? If it’s this good, hell, yes! Support Eagle business and eat here soon.

This is the best Italian food since I was in Florence. Most items are made from scratch. The owner is on the floor socializing with customers while his brother is in the kitchen cooking. Family owned and operated by truly nice people!!!

Claims best burgers in Eagle, but far from it. Place was pricey and don’t expect more than a couple of fries and one dipping cup of ketchup. Oh, and ask prices. Didn’t think a can of coke would cost me $1.75. This is twice I been here; first and last.

The service was fantastic. Our waitress was paying close attention to every detail and made the experience that much better. Add Panang and green curry and they were both great.