Search

Review of The Surfing Goat Coffee & Bagel Bar

The Surfing Goat Coffee & Bagel Bar is a charming sandwich and coffee shop located in the heart of Tybee Island, Georgia. With its laid-back beach vibe and delicious menu offerings, it has become a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike.

As the name suggests, The Surfing Goat Coffee & Bagel Bar specializes in serving up mouthwatering bagels and expertly brewed coffee. Whether you're craving a classic plain bagel with cream cheese or a more adventurous flavor combination, this place has got you covered. The bagels are always fresh and toasted to perfection, and the toppings are made with high-quality ingredients. The menu also includes a variety of light sandwiches, perfect for a quick bite before hitting the beach.

One of the standout features of The Surfing Goat Coffee & Bagel Bar is its friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The staff is known for their exceptional customer service, always going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The shop itself is cozy and inviting, with beach-themed decor that adds to its charm.

While the food and service are top-notch, it's worth noting that the shop can get a bit crowded during peak hours. However, the wait is well worth it for the delicious food and friendly service you'll receive.

The Surfing Goat Coffee & Bagel Bar is open from 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM every day of the week, making it the perfect spot for a leisurely breakfast or a mid-morning pick-me-up. Whether you're a local looking for your go-to coffee spot or a visitor in search of a tasty meal, this place is definitely worth a visit.

From the business

"Coffee and bagel shop"

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

The Surfing Goat Coffee & Bagel Bar Reviews - 33

3.6
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Joe C.

I stopped in for breakfast. Their drip coffee is good, though maybe just a little expensive. I had a sausage, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel and was surprised to find the eggs were hard-boiled and sliced, which I thought worked really well. The space is warmly decorated, sunny, and clean. Staff was awesome and service was both friendly and prompt. It's a very convenient spot and I'll definitely be back next time I am down.

Becky Phillips

My first time visiting here. I send people here from the Hotel constantly when they ask for a coffee/brunch place to eat. So I needed to try it for myself. I LOVE IT!! I got the "Doin' Things Right" bagel. Bacon, egg and American cheese on a cheddar bagel. It was delicious and very large. Girls behind the counter were super nice and helpful. I will be a frequent customer!!! Take a few minutes to get your food, but that's because they are making it from scratch. No heat lamps. Fresh toasted bagel, fresh cracked egg and fresh cooked bacon. Worth the wait!! Great service, atmosphere, and food!! Bagels are very large and priced well. Great job guys!! Keep it up!!
And their shirts are freaking adorable!! Had to get one.

Samantha Ballew

We had the Morning Dew bagel. The Let It Grow looks great as well. All ingredients were fresh and the bagel was toasted perfectly.

Deb Baber

We thought the food was good. A little pricey but so is everything. We want them to make it but they won't if they don't pick up the pace and tend to the customers. We went in on Wednesday and no one acknowledged us. There were about 5 people in there and one man was on the phone and never looked up. When you come in people need to acknowledge and say have a seat, can I start you with coffee. Nothing like that happened. I am not impatient but I want service

emma owens

was excited 3 days in a row about this cute beach bagel shop only to find out they were out of bagels one day out of bagels and egg the next day and then there bagel maker couldn’t make it the next. i hope next year when i come back down this business is thriving so i can give it a try! good luck surfing goat

Ashleigh Ransonette

Such a gem! Love the atmosphere and bagels. The bagel was toasted on both sides which elevated the sandwich so much! True game changer. Each order is made to order, so there is a slight wait but truly worth it.

Tara Acree

Pros: Good Coffee, the staff was polite. Cute coffee bar decor
Cons: I waited over 25 minutes for 2 coffees, I was one of 5 people in there and 12 min in they let me know they forgot I ordered, another 12 min for 2 black coffees. The staff was walking around texting and talking which was good for being social, bad when you only have 5 customers and make them wait almost half an hour.

Brittni Souder

Review edited from 1 star to 4 for good customer service and owner making amends & changes after our bad experience. Our costs were refunded & a toaster has been purchased among other efforts to improve the customer’s experience. Would give this place another try if we came back to the area.

Original review: Terribly overpriced for bad food. Ordered a bacon egg & cheese on a toasted bagel. Was given a disgusting bagel that was hot, but wasn’t toasted at all and the eggs were sliced hard boiled eggs. Floppy bacon. Four of us came and all of us took one bite and threw it out.
Coffee was good.

Elliott Hutchinson

Great little spot right near the beach for coffee and light sandwiches. I got a breakfast bagel with sausage and egg and it was very tasty! Definitely recommend for a quick morning or early afternoon bite.

Sal Vitale

Do NOT get food here. They don’t have a toaster for the bagels and for the eggs they use room temperature sliced hard boiled eggs. Who does that?? Bacon was way undercooked and floppy, they probably microwave or steam it. Spent over 23 dollars for my wife and I to each just throw out our bagel sandwiches after one bite (wife spit out her bite).

UPDATE:
Owner reached out and made the situation right. They even got a toaster to offer that as an option now. Thank you for listening.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload