Mallery Street Cafe

Love, love, love this little cafe! The food is absolutely delicious! The service is always great and the prices are just right! The Monte Cristo is a must have… it’s the best one I’ve had! You won’t be disappointed! Yum!

Just wanted a light lunch. The service was exceptional. Friendly and prompt. Ordered a hot chicken salad. Chicken was not spicy, the menu stated it was. More dressing or an extra portion would have been good.

This place it's great! The food and the service can't be beat! Definitely coming back here next time I'm on the island!

Our favorite breakfast spot on the island. Not too fancy, just real good food. Lunches are done with Sanderson big a giant would have leftovers.

It's awesome!

It's clean. Though, the menus could be fixed & maintained better. It's my recommendation that you could laminate menus & place on walls of each table (perhaps surrounded by cute frames). This way, menus are handled less (& also creates less of a catalyst for destruction) & dirty hands aren't contaminating them therefore it would help reduce plastic waste & tree health which allows humans to breathe better oxygen & furthers our initiative to cleaner atmosphere & Earth.

Service is great.

Food is even better.

If you are familiar with my other reviews (see 'my contributions') you'll know I never give 5stars unless it's absolutely perfect. Perfection is hard to attain so I rarely rate that many. I also have high standards. It's my opinion the world won't change 1 iota without extreme considerations. I think reviewers rate way too easily without much thought.

The only other thing I would concern myself with, to grab that elusive 5th star, is make things less cluttered. There's an empty golf bag, coats hanging about, purses laying around, etc. These objects are employees personal items. It makes it seem clumsy & uncared for or neglectful. In which case it may, subconsciously, equate to (or make someone consider) the food or service could be (or become) neglectful. I'm observant & I consider all angles so I know that's not the case but it certainly couldn't help to clean some things up around there, either.

My thoughts while eating there today were that they should expand their business. I think they would want to stay local: service can remain the same & management can control the little details better. On the other hand, I know this great little restaurant that began the same way.

Bob Evans has expanded exponentially. They're choices were first breakfast meals. Their service standards were excellent so they could compensate for expansions. Granted, not every Bob Evans is grand but, Mallory's is the type of standard that makes for a serious consideration for growth. As long as you keep the service on fresh food, customers & community you'll go far.

The other reason for 4stars is their involvement in community. An island vibe (& island mentality) is fantastic so if you convey this throughout your relations then you could become unmatched.

Keep it up!

We made our mark on their table today because the food is so fresh! We also were able to easily watch the Veterans day parade! You can tell community is important to them. I appreciate this.

Update! We came back the next wknd. Was busy, no tables inside. We're die hard fans enough to sit outside in the cold (48°F!). Here's another 2 pics for evidence [5total]! ;)

My experience here was awesome! I read other reviews and all were positive so I had to give it a try and I very pleased! The breakfast was excellent! Customer service was impeccable. Anna R. Was very kind, knowledgeable and friendly. Made our dining experience memorable. Thank you. Definitely will be back. ( we’re visiting from Atlanta, GA)

Great food and service, 2nd time here this week! Will be our go to for breakfast, Thank you!

Went here for lunch on day date with my wife. We were both off work and had no big plans. Get some lunch and take pup to the dog park. We were able to sit outside. Servers were great. My wife had Greek Salad with salmon. She said it was fantastic. I had the club and hand cut fries. Holy smokes, that was a big sandwich. I ate half and just finished the other half for supper, as I type this review. Boars Head cuts on the sandwich. Coke products and good tea. Don't remember our server's name, but she was super sweet and attentive. A dog lover, herself. Great neighborhood local joint to grab lunch and enjoy the day. We will go again.

Nice little place for breakfast. My wife loved the biscuits and gravy but I didn't care for them. (My wife makes them way better from scratch.) My egg, cheese, and sausage biscuit was good.

Love the food! Love the staff! Love the location!! Rocco likes it too! Best place on the Island for lunch or breakfast!!