Buffalo Cafe at the Old Bank

I enjoyed the hamburger and fries, and of course, sweet tea.

Limited choices for food in Plains, but we took a chance. It was mid week and we went around 6 pm. We were the only ones in the place. Order at the counter and have a seat, then they bring your food. My daughter had chicken fingers and fries, my husband had BBQ and tater tots. Both came with coleslaw. I ordered a hamburgers and fries. My burger was one of the best I’ve ever had! It was big and had the freshest bun. They don’t skimp on the portions here. Prices are average. We spent about $30 on dinner.Another couple came in and they told stories about President Carter and visiting with him. After we left we saw lots of folks coming for dinner. Apparently they eat later here! You can drive to Americus for more options, but if Buffalo is open, I would recommend you stay on Main Street.

This place was super cool, the old vault really made the cafe super rare. The staff was very friendly and helpful with great recommendations. I had the chicken salad which was delicious and probably the best I have ever had. If I ever get back to Plains I'll definitely be eating here!

Found ourselves in Plains accidentally. (My wife missed a turn to the south many miles back).
What a treat for us.
It was lunchtime so we ate at the Buffalo Cafe at the Old Bank.
Service was outstanding food was fresh and excellent. The unsweetened tea a treat for my wife and the coffee was very good.

Great service and amazing food! Oh, and fast. I called ahead and my food was ready just moments after I arrived. I highly recommend them to anyone in the area or traveling through!

Delicious Club sandwich and Philly cheesesteak. It's nice to walk into the restaurant and see the history of the old bank. Great place to eat!

Great staff and great food, best hamburger stake around, cheese burgers are awesome. We drive 40 miles to eat here and enjoyed every time. Mr and Mrs JC

Chilli cheese fries were terrible. The Chilli was just dried up ground beef. The hamburger steak sandwich tasted like a microwaved patty.

Love the BBQ plate and onion rings.

Great little restaurant. Very affordable. Food was great. They were crowded but worth the wait.