Brooklyn Water Bagel

I had a "Carnegie Deli" pastrami sandwich bagel for an eye-watering $16. The pastrami was pretty good, albeit a bit salty. Forced tipping through the credit card machine probably means you're not paying your employees enough.

Love their bagels. The only problem was they use TV screens to display their menus and too many were out so we couldn't see all the sandwiches they offer. Now I know to use their APP to order. They are busy. Sandwiches look fantastic!

REAL Bagels
I've had bagels in Brooklyn as well as the other 4 boroughs in NYC and these taste like they came from their namesake. Sooo much better than the white bread when a hole in the middle that I have gotten from so many other places.

These bagels have glorious gluten and plentiful toppings I am partial to the sesame seed version. Recommended

Great food, selection of bagels, sandwiches, breakfast, awesome service, and friendly staff.

These are some good bagels. Love the Reuben. They know how to make food. Coming from a person that is particular about food and can appreciate it. They treat you like family here. Come in a few times and they know you by face. Always warm welcome. Highly recommend!!!!!

Ordered through door dash - the store did not pack the cream cheese which was one of only 5 items ordered. Shouldn’t be that difficult. Second time this has happened. When called to tell them the girl was rude and basically hung up on my husband. Will not be giving them anymore business.

Bagels are great. I ordered a sandwich with egg cheese and pork roll. They advertise pork roll as Taylor Ham which is not uncommon. If you order pork roll or are from the northeast you know what Im talking about. She didnt know what I was talking about so we talked through it..so I thought. I get home with my sandwich and its what seems to be black forest ham. A little disappointed but it was good. Bagels are worth it. Sandwiches not so much.

The muffins! Oh my goodness! They are divine. Blueberry and chocolate chip... heat them up about 35 seconds when you get home and enjoy a little slice of heaven. They were very busy but the service was still quick and friendly. Be warned though... their food is addictive.

Very good bagels - probably not THE number one best most legit bagel out there - but a great chew, good flavor, and fresh. Breakfast sandwich was great, fluffy eggs and not at all greasy.

Rounding up for the great customer service - doordash was bugged and not letting me choose what bagels I wanted in my half dozen correctly, but it was the only available option for delivery. So I thought I'd call in and let them know my name and which ones I actually wanted. Having never ordered from here before, I figured there's maybe a 50/50 chance of the person answering being either confused or unmotivated to help. However, the person who answered (on Sunday 11/22/20 around 12:30p) immediately understood and took my order, which made it to me exactly as I described.

They are the champions of bagles.
Check out for yourself. You'll agree!