City Hall Cafe & Wine bar

Nice selection of wine. Came for dinner and sat outside. Menu brought quickly. I ordered a glass of Pinot Grigio. Good flavor. Ordered fresh catch of day with almond. Came with green beans and mashed potatoes. Fish and beans were good. Potatoes ok. Hubby had some chicken which he liked. Reason for 4 stars is service slowed down to us more than other guests. Otherwise a good place.

Such a Great locally owned Bistro. Seriously good consistent meal every time you go. The quality is always awesome time and time again, City Hall is a must go to if you enjoy eating a great meal and having some nice wine or even a huge beer selection. When you go Gabby is the Best and so is Michala these two ladies offer some of the best service that you can ever want they are over the top wonderful people they also offer relentless smiles that will infect your senses that even with a bad day will make you smile and be glad you are there. City Hall cafe is an absolute must dine in whether it’s a lunch or dinner, you will be happy that you did.

Im very happy I live near this place. So far everything I've tried has been amazing! Friendly staff. Very big wine selection.

Great food, awesome staff, awesome service! I love coming here when I am in town!! They have a rotating daily special menu with everything from homemade soup to pasta salad to fresh fish tacos to any kind of sandwich your heart desires. Local residents love this place too which is the true sign of a good restaurant in the keys!!

Loved this place. Stopped in for a bite to eat on our way to the beach. Excellent subs, sandwiches, craft beer and wine. Extremely friendly staff. Highly recommend.

Best food we ate in the keys. Absolutely delicious by any standard. Great wine selection. Highly recommend! Thank you so much for an excellent meal.

Good lunch, friendly staff. Inexpensive and great specials. I had the Thai crab cake wrap it was delicious. Seeing celebrities in our neighborhood is always lots of fun, great to see Wyland supporting City Hall Cafe. Sat right under a huge fantastic painting he did. Lunch surrounded by creativity! Downside? I wish there were soap in the bathroom and I wish the staff member I told acted like that mattered.

Came in for a quick bite, and told the server about the a story the bar tender at our resort told us...

Basically implying that it was harder then it seemed getting key limes in the keys.

Our sever had a puzzled look and explained to us that we could probably fine key lime outside on a tree relatively easy...

We thought nothing of this information, but knew that someone was/is lying.

Our meal came and it was great... And as we were winding down what seemed to be the delivery driver came in. With what, you ask? A bag of key limes. That they were happy to share with us. Hip hip hip hop hooray 🙏🙏🙏

Service was great, food was excellent. Ordered a buffalo chicken wrap and a chicken Cesar wrap with cole slaw and pasta salad and was definitely not disappointed. For a meal so simple they really kicked it up a notch. Will most definitely be back for lunch next time I’m back in town. 👍🏼

Seriously good steak sandwich! Good size portions with fries. I have eaten here 3 times so far and they never disappoint! The staff is super friendly and always on point.