The Secret Stash
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
The Secret Stash Reviews - 100
4.7
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Ethan Unverferth
🥹😃I’m not sure words can accurately describe what you experience when you come to The Secret Stash… the vibe, the food, it’s all beyond incredible! I’d highly recommend stopping in here, no matter where you’re from! Absolutely delicious in every way possible.
Drew Walton
Secret stash does generally have it going on. Big reputation for visiting folk and I get why. They do file you in there tight though so be prepped to socialize with your table neighbors. My pizza last time honestly didn't quite live up. Got the Mac daddy and I thought it would really feature that shaved steak. Disappointed to see it lightly sprinkled on there. Worth a visit but nowadays the town features other good options
Melina Rossbach
This spot is so cool! Pizza and salad were both delish and the owner is super friendly!
Kevin Dee
We were walking down the center of town and the aroma of the cuisine enticed us inside. It was my first time to Crested Butte but it wont be my last. The pizza was superb and the Meatball and Monkey God sub is stellar. The crack fries were excellent. The only negative I have is that the appetizer came out after the main course. The frozen strawberry lemonade was a refreshing treat.
Scott Park
Don't know his name, but our tall middle-aged server was rude. We almost got up and walked out. The pizza was really good, although a little pricey, but we still will not return.
Kristina Maynard
Eclectic restaurant in historic Crested Butte.
Unique pizzas, slushy cocktails and tons of kitschy charm. Quality ingredients set this place apart from other pizza joints.
Denise
This pizza place is amazing!
I’m vegan so I loved the vegan pizza I brought it home to freeze and treasure I haven’t found anything like this.
My family love the wings, and traditional pizza.
The ambiance is amazing, service you won’t regret it!
Chad Martin
Live here, the only place I get pizza. Great service. Love the staff. They give back to the community school in a big way. The owner is peaceful and cares about the employees. They are always nice to my kids too. The other pizza place is aggressive and it isn’t the same quality.
Kelly Epifanio
Groovy little pizza shop in DT Crested Butte. Been around over a decade. Menu has been streamlined but there are still great combos to be had. We had the Notorious FIG with a side of arugula. Claim to have the best margarita in town but I hope that's not true🥺 . Friendly owner, manager and servers. Definitely a must do when in CB.
Katelyn Inman
Absolutely phenomenal pizza and apps. Staff is so friendly. Can't wait to come back again!