The Secret Stash

Always loved going here to grab a slice an beer when I lived in Crested Butte. now anytime I come to town to visit friends and board this is a must have for me.
Crack fries and the sticky icky sauce is honestly so addicting and the sticky icky is amazing to dip the crust in .
the atmosphere is elaborate but simple.
where's the beef is honestly one of my favorite pizzas I've had from here and I've had a good portion of the menu.
the meatball pizza was amazing too.
I'm looking forward to trying the vegan meatball pizza next time i visit.
the owners are amazing.
BRENDAN was my waiter and also the manager on duty . the guy is awesome. he took such good care of us. from the drinks to the food.

keep slaying it cant wait to eat here again.

Will not disappoint! Very cool place with plenty of in and outdoor seating. Drinks are excellent and the pizza is spot on. I got the gluten free crust and it was awesome. Chicken wings with dry rub was good! They were huge.

My friend and I were in town snowboarding and we decided to give this place a try on a Thursday evening. We arrived around 6pm and was seated right away. The atmosphere is unique and fascinating. We ordered stash wings and two pizzas: Notorious F.I.G. and You’re Driving Me Caprese. Hands down one of the best pizzas we’ve had. This place does get super busy in the evenings, so if you want to avoid a long wait, I recommend arriving 6pm or earlier.

Also, the owner and staffs are incredible. I purchased one of their t-shirts at their shop and realized later that I needed a smaller size. I was no longer in town, so I contacted the restaurant; and the owner was very kind to ship out the correct size. Their customer service is phenomenal! Add this place to your list if you ever find yourself in Crested Butte.

Folks it's the Secret Stash. Yes, there might be a small wait or maybe not. Either way just go. The family went for a late lunch and it was everything you would want after a full morning outdoors. The restaurant is as comfortable as can be and the pizza speaks for itself. Just read the reviews. It was delicious. I would say if you are going for the crack fries which are mandatory and delicious and the crack wings which are just as good, just think about the size of your pizzas. It was all so good. The restaurant staff was fantastic and friendly. I can't recall a place that matched $1000 tips to the kitchen staff. As you can see, many have crossed that line. Well deserved.

Unique, Friendly, Amazing atmosphere, absolutely incredible pizza. We came to Crested Butte for a snowboarding trip and I’m so happy that we came to The Secret Stash to eat. The staff was friendly. The place was slammed busy and I can’t express enough how incredible the pizza and wings and crack fries were. Thank you so much we really had a great time. We came two of the nights because it was so great!

Amazing fries and the most flavorful bowl of pasta with chicken, pesto, artichoke hearts and roasted red peppers. Oh wow, enough for two and we still had leftovers for hotel. Met the manager Paula, who has been there 20 years. She is a hard worker and really waited on tables and managed the other waiters at the same time. Best find of 2022

One word. BOMB! Kelsey our waitress was super nice and the place had a trendy vipe. They had fun music playing, crazy decor and great food. We got the crack fries which were crispy and amazing served with a sauce that seemed a cross between Mayo and thousand island with a sesame seed too. The meatball pie was great with huge pieces of roasted garlic The 16” could have fed 4 people. The strawberry mojito strong and tasty!

Great pizza! We got a couple of pies to go after a long day on the slopes. I’m glad we did because it would’ve been a long wait for a table. Love the funky decor inside. We got the meatball pizza which was fantastic the sauce and garlic on it were so tasty. We also got the Hampton which was also great and really fresh tasting with the arugula. We’ll definitely be stopping here in the future.

The Secret Stash is my favorite pizza in Colorado. They have such great, creative pizzas. They have a great atmosphere, great staff, and great drinks. Definitely stop by when in Crested Butte!

I have been visiting Crested Butte, Colorado for several summers in a row, and I always visit The Secret Stash for their excellent pizza at least once or twice every trip.

Sometimes we order takeout, but this past Sunday my brother and I decided to eat inside onsite.

We arrived around 7pm and there was no wait for a table (probably because it was raining, usually there is a wait especially for the outdoor tables on a nice day).

We ordered 12 buffalo wings, which came with ranch dressing for $18. We also ordered a large Spicy Wais pizza for $34, which came with Traditional sauce, sriracha swirl, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, chopped garlic, cilantro, tomato & fresh jalapeños.

The buffalo wings were so big and the pizza so large that we ended up taking half a pizza home for breakfast the next morning (and yes it was just as delicious).

The staff is friendly, and they do let you know that pizzas may take up to an hour when the restaurant is busy. Ours came in about half an hour.

There is also a fun retail store with Secret Stash-branded apparel and other gear and trinkets which is always a great thing to check out while waiting for your takeout pizza or your table.