Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • In-store shopping
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Slice of Heaven Bakery Reviews - 44

4.8
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Brittney

Cinnamon roll was big and could taste it was home made. The sweet cream vanilla cold brew tasted like straight milk and sugar.. didn’t seem to have any coffee taste to it or look like it. Recommend to order black for drinks.

Patrick Cox

Where to begin? My wife Samm and I have known Rebecca since she worked at ODC in Rapids. Because of her wonderful people skills, genuine personality, and immediate warmth, we were delighted when she and her husband upended “Slice of Heaven” in Rome, WI. No longer a need to travel to the other Rome or Vienna for her delicious “treats from the heart!”
One more accolade as to how genuine Rebecca is: I happened to be in Riverview Hospital for a few days, of which wife Samm told her while picking up my favorite cinnamon coffee cake. Alas, who walked into my room today with her Slice of Heaven smile and treats?!
Remember, she starts baking at 2:30AM. She took precious time because of who she is.
Thank you, Rebecca and your wonderful SLICE OF HEAVEN.

Pat & Samm

Jacob Carlson

Everything we’ve had has been excellent at worst, the English muffin bread is absurdly good. Very reasonably priced for the quality. Easily the best bakery we’ve found since moving up to central WI. Lives up to its name!

Lori Pritzl

Scrumptious fresh bakery for any sweet craving you have. The breads are amazing as well. They also serve great coffee and other tasty beverages. Don't forget about the premium ice cream they are scooping! Worth every calorie, but who is counting. The owner, Rebecca is super, as is her team! Our community of Rome is so lucky to have them.

Shannon Byrd

Rebecca is an excellent baker and an even better human. Slice of Heaven is lovely.

Paul Morrison

Rebecca at Slice of Heaven is THE BEST! We've had the chance to have many cakes, cupcakes, cookies, etc. from her and the items are always top quality, beautifully decorated and packaged, and (for things ordered in advance) ready to go when we need them. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! As a bonus, she is super friendly and pretty funny, as well.

Jessica Schroeder

Rebecca’s creations at Slice of Heaven not only look like pieces of art, they taste like pieces of art. Actual little morsels of heaven in each bite. From her extremely artistic cakes, to her adult (boozy) cupcakes, to her chocolate chip cookies.. you’ll never be disappointed! Becky is completely self taught and self built from the ground up, beginning in her own home kitchen cooking for family and friends. She has come so far to finally have her own bakery. She can do just about anything you ask for. Not only is she talented but she’s a genuinely GOOD human being at her core.

Juan Vergara

Unfortunately was unable to try this apparently nice place. Drove with the whole family, to find out they had closed before business hours. “Sold out” sign on the door.

google user

The pumpkin and rootbeer cupcakes....pretty good..but nothing exciting.
Had vanilla cupcakes the other day and they were awful. The frosting tasted like great value milk chocolate frosting. Either not fresh or not homemade. Not worth it at $3 a cupcake. Will look other places

Matthew Taub

Great cappuccino and homemade bread. Great addition to Rome! The staff is super friendly too.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload

Slice of Heaven Bakery Hours

  • Monday
  • Tuesday
  • Wednesday 6 AM to 2 PM
  • Thursday 6 AM to 2 PM
  • Friday 6 AM to 2 PM
  • Saturday 6 AM to 2 PM
  • Sunday 8 AM to 1 PM