Fiddleheads Coffee Menomonee Falls

Stopped here on our way from Milwaukee to Appleton in search of a coffee shop that wasn’t a big chain. Right off the bat, the environment was nice. The place is nicely furnished and has plenty of seating (inside and outside) to accommodate larger groups.

I ordered a cold brew with Oat Milk, and while I could tell that the coffee was high quality, it was not as strong as cold brew coffee should be. Cold brew should always be brewed extra strong to compensate for the melting ice!

I also had a bacon/egg/cheese breakfast sandwich, which was great. The “zesty mayo” was on point, and the sandwich wasn’t too greasy or sloppy. Everyone in my group was happy with their food, but apparently they cannot do any modifications to the sandwiches, which is odd. When my friend asked for cheese on his sandwich, they said they could not add it.

Overall this place is a cool vibe, and a welcome change from the usual Starbucks/Dunkin chains, but has a few small areas for improvement.

Just an average coffee shop. Absolutely nothing wrong with the place, the food, or the service. Just didn't find anything particularly unique about it inside or on the menu. If it wasn't for the mural outside, I'd totally forget all about this place. Perfectly fine place to stop in if you are in the area and need a coffee though.

Good coffee and nice staff. A plus mini bakery 😍, clean place with nice atmosphere

Simply the best Iced Mocha I've ever had. Blended properly, just the right amount of mocha and milk. Also had the english muffin with bacon, egg, and cheese. Phenomenal!
The environment is welcoming and open. Great for getting a little laptop work done and then moving on. I can't wait to see it with the garage door open in the spring!

Comfortable shop with good coffee, The menu has some nice options but they will not customize sandwiches. For example adding avocado to a sandwich even though it's made from scratch is not possible because they can't ring it up in the computer... Odd. Maybe that's a training issue.

Otherwise the food is simple and the coffee is good and it's a nice stop in that side of town with limited breakfast options.

This was the first time at this location. I loved the layout and decor. The staff was helpful and friendly. I had a breakfast sandwich that was delicious. I also had a peppermint mocha as I had a birthday coupon for a free drink to use 😍

Place was insanely busy. Food came out way before drinks were ready. If you are sitting in for food, drinks should come with it. Had to let food get cold while standing in a never ending line. Coffee was good. Food was definitely not worth the $8 per sandwich for a one egg sandwich on a small English muffin.

I’ve been here two times. First time I ordered caramel s’mores, but in menu didn’t say that it’s iced coffee, anyway it was so good, but too sweet. Also I ordered bagel with cream cheese. Was Okay. Second time I ordered latte with banana syrup. This just regular latte made my day, it was one of the best in my life! Also I ordered Prosciutto Melt, if owner read this, you have to change your prosciutto supplier, taste not good. The cheapest prosciutto in Walmart taste better and more real then yours. This is so good coffee place, but not for food.
P.S. thank you for sides of lemon for all customers, I don’t think I saw this before anywhere 😉

Great coffee but very pricey. A hot cider was almost $7! Happy to support a small business but it was a little more expensive than I anticipated. Staff is very kind and very attentive. Atmosphere is wonderful.

Surprisingly Disappointing 😞
I met a small group of friends at this location and was initially impressed with the decor & cleanliness. However that was largely overshadowed by the fact that when I order a Chicken Salad sandwich without the bread I was told by two employees that was NOT POSSIBLE. Are you kidding me? I can't order just the chicken salad? So disappointed at the inflexibility of the staff. I will not visit any locations because this is unacceptable for customers in my opinion. It was a simple & easy request that was not granted.