Search

Review of Mission Hill Coffee House

Mission Hill Coffee House is a cozy coffee shop located at 794 Chebomnicon Rd in La Pointe, Wisconsin. This local gem is known for its good coffee, great sandwiches, and friendly staff.

Upon entering Mission Hill Coffee House, you'll be greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The shop is small but charming, with a laid-back and friendly vibe that is typical of Madeline Island. The staff is known for their exceptional customer service, always ready to assist and provide recommendations for things to do on the island.

The coffee at Mission Hill Coffee House is highly praised by customers. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cup of joe or a specialty drink, they have you covered. The sandwiches are also a hit, with customers raving about their quality and taste. The menu offers a variety of options to satisfy different preferences and dietary needs.

While some customers have mentioned that the shop can be a bit disorganized and cluttered, the overall consensus is that the quality of the coffee and food outweighs any minor inconveniences. The shop may not have the most extensive hours, but it's worth planning your visit accordingly to experience the delicious offerings.

If you're looking for a friendly and laid-back coffee shop on Madeline Island, Mission Hill Coffee House is a must-visit. Enjoy a cup of their excellent coffee, indulge in a tasty sandwich, and soak in the welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this charming coffee shop is sure to leave you satisfied and wanting to come back for more.

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Mission Hill Coffee House Reviews - 63

4.1
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Claire Thielman

Loved this coffee shop! Good coffee and sandwiches at a good price. The woman running it was super friendly and helpful, and she advised us on some fun things to do during the off season around the island. Came back a second time for more coffee!

Lance Stedman

Good coffee, GREAT sandwiches and even nicer staff. Couldn’t love this place more!

Philip McMonagle

We spent the last two days on Madeline Island. I stopped for coffee both mornings, the rolls are good the coffee is really good. This morning I ordered a chocolate chip cookie, she asked me if I wanted it well done or raw! I laughed out loud because I had never heard that before. So it's a fun place, stop by.

Kaela B

There is truly nothing to complain about in this shop. It is an eccentric woman's place and you are obviously not intended to sit inside 😝 Plenty of outdoor seating. If you enjoy a conversation with your barista and a family run atmosphere, this is a good choice. Coffee and a bfast sammy is just a bonus. Lots of things to look at. Fold it back up if you unfold a shirt. Follow the rules if you don't like a mess! This ain't your momma's house.

Gerald McClintock

Shop is a mess, disorganized, placing orders and transactions are a process. Not busy but it took FOREVER for the older lady to take and process orders. Her husband sat and did nothing while her 20 something grandson talked about drunken friends while also did not lend a hand . Keep in mind all they do is coffee, sandwiches and cookies. My sandwich had two hairs and I never received the cookies. Wasn’t going to go through the process to try and get them . Husband and adult grandson also didn’t get the outdoor tables set up for Memorial Day weekend.

Amy Mullins

As the only open coffee spot on the island, we had no choice but to stop in. The woman ignored us while she worked on a crossword puzzle. When she felt like it she took our order with no hospitable manner whatsoever. I asked if she’d cut the roll in half. She slapped a knife on the counter saying ”I’ve got 4 kids. I don’t cut up food for anyone!” The roll was dry, maybe day old? The coffee was good. However, her manner was very unfriendly for a place that makes it’s living off of tourists. And the shop was a dirty mess.

riley spenny

i ordered a mocha coffe and the lady took plain coffee and just added in chocolate syrup, and i asked for a lid and was told there was no more,
but when i was seated outside i saw people who had came in after me with lids on their coffee, when i tried to ask for a lid a second time she still refused to give me a lid.

Josiah Cornett

Great sandwiches and nice service staff.

It’s kind of small and only has four dining tables—two of which were covered stuff in they apparently couldn’t find shelf space for.
The remaining two tables were usually taken, even on a slow day. If they would just clear off their other two tables, the dining area would be more welcoming and less cluttered.

Y A

It's a little chaotic in here. Stuff laying on top of stuff and seems unorganized. But the coffee was good and that's all that mattered.

I recommend this place.

Linda Parranto

I believe Marie is the only coffee place on the island open year round. Either way, she and her staff are always very kind and the coffee is always really good. A latte with some of the honey on the counter is one of my favorite things to have while I sit out front of the shop and look at the lake and our version of a town square.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload